1837
« on: May 27, 2009, 05:25:07 PM »
Nefertiti (Mana Khemia) vs. Battle on the Big Bridge (Final Fantasy V) - Nefertiti's a truly amazing song, whereas Gilgamesh suffers majorly from the retro music quality problem, as CK's said. While it's a brilliantly made piece, both of them are, and the quality of Nefertiti tips the scales in its favour.
STIGMATA (Mana Khemia) vs. Battle Hymn of the Soul/Battle for Everyone's Souls (Persona 3) - Stigmata's an odd one. I like it, and I know I've claimed it to be a potential winner before, but I'm just not seeing it today. It's good, but a little too quick to change and jumps between several styles in quick succession. Battle Hymn is... also an odd song, but it's a pretty consistently good one. Again, changes between styles pretty quickly, but it suits the mood of the song more. I'm gonna have to go with Battle Hymn, if only because it's really grown on me over the duration of this tournament, whereas Stigmata's been pretty much ignored.
The Fate ~ Cluster Amaryllis (Shadow Hearts Covenant) vs. Awe of She (Guilty Gear XX) - Odd. Fate starts out as kinda meh to me, whereas Awe kicks in from the start and strikes me as an awesome song. It then repeats what seems like about 20 seconds of music throughout the whole song, whereas Fate becomes this amazing piece that I can really imagine working in-game (despite me not having heard it in SH:C) and works out of game as well, hence winning this match. (If this were You're Not Alone instead of Awe, it'd've been better. ;o)
The Meaning of Birth (Tales of the Abyss) vs. Marionette Messiah (Super Robot Wars OGs) - Difficult. Birth didn't hold my attention for too long, but what was there was pretty damn amazing. Marionette, alternatively, was catchy, but pretty poorly done past that. Thing is, I can re-listen to Birth and realise that it is pretty damn good, and good enough to be Marionette.
Battle with the Four Fiends (Final Fantasy IV) vs. Prisoners of Fate (Chrono Cross) - Wait, why is Prisoners in the final 16? >_> Four Fiends is classic, Prisoners is meh. Easy choice~
Faith is for the Transient People (Mountain of Faith) vs. EXEC_SPHILIA/. (Ar Tonelico 2) - Faith is definitely an awesome piece. Upbeat, nice to listen to and good quality all at once. Potential finalist, maybe~? Exec's good, but definitely nowhere near good enough to beat Faith.
Main Theme (Orchestral) (Parasite Eve) vs. Into the Wilderness (Wild ARMs) - It doesn't matter which one I vote for here. My quick count has the score at 13-5, so Wilderness has probably lost. But hell, I've voted on the rest already, I'm gonna vote this one. Although neither one particularly appeals to me. Meh, PE Theme kept my interest more, I'll go with that one.
Dream of the Shore Bordering Another World (Chrono Cross) vs. Song of Mana (Legend of Mana) - Song of Mana anti-vote. Am I about the only person here who can't stand this song? >_> Dream, on the other hand, is pretty damn awesome in its own way, although I don't see it being finals-quality.