POST NOTE: I'm making points as I read through the thread, so if things have already been said, its because I've made my remarks before I got to whatever someone else had posted. Only thing I knew at the start of post was that Sylon had dropped from the game.
QuietRain (0): EvilTom
I hate to be fussy over small things, but that wasn't actually me.
And yeah, it was me that did the jokevote against you Rain. Doesn't really matter though, I can't exactly lynch you anyways
------------------------------
Ryogo, you've been around since this all went down, as evidenced by your avatar and flavor text change. What are your opinions on the situation?
First of all, yes, I was around for until about 12:30 AM (T-2:30 hours to deadline for me). I didn't post anything because, well, I didn't have anything to say at the time :S I still felt the Sylon Case was the best we had at the time. Obviously, that's changed now.
If I had've seen this before I logged out and went to bed for the night, I would whipped up a post with my thoughts. But this was posted about an hour after I went to bed. I actually wasn't around for a lot of the stuff you think I was. But I will give you my comments and thoughts about it!
Snowfire having a townie vibe on Sylon really irked me, earlier. He hadn't done anything, and drew all his conclusions from what other people were doing around him. Then he didn't even actually go after any of 'em (let's not forget that part of his hypothesis was 'lots of people voting for one guy seems bad and untrustworthy'), instead focusing on the unrelated Xanth. Yeah sure don't vote Sylon because you think he's just sick or whatever, but actually going out and saying 'he's townlike!' is way too weird.
Have to agree on your thought process here by Rat. SF's logic here is not the best of logic to follow... Its just downright horrible.
Xanth is average - 5.
Sylon is, to me, mildly townie - 4.
SnowFire is extremely townie - 0.
SirAlex is, to me, mildly scummy - 6.
If the choice is between Xanth and Sylon - well, 5>4 ! Thus it may make sense to vote for a "random" - if the only other options are even worse.
If Alex was scummier to you, why didn't you put your votes down for him?? 5 may be greater than 4, but 6 is even larger than both! This is just adding strikes to the board. (Reading on later, noticed Delta makes the same point, so I guess I second it.)
Also, I noticed that OblivionKnight and Strago have tried to keep a particularly low profile as well, specially the later. I just think Sylon's case is worse right now for actively trying to keep it down even when the attention was onto him.
Strago, maybe. He's been talking, if not frequently, but at least he's participating.
OK? I'm not sure "Low profile" counts so much as he hasn't been here at all. As I said, though, I haven't seen him much online in the past 24 hours at all, so there's a good chance he actually has legit RL reasons; though if this keeps up throughout the next day, I'm expecting a modkill.
Also seconded. I'd really like to hear from OK, but at this point it seems like that'll have to wait until tomorrow? If he doesn't show, he'll be MK'd and if he does, we can light a fire under his ass later.
Same goes for Strago, but to a much lesser degree. See much more from him now, am happy.
]Ryogo says something here about Carthrat on which I call shenanigans in a big way: http://www.rpgdl.com/forums/index.php?topic=3132.msg54979#msg54979. Namely that because he hasn’t shown up on the “active users logged in” list, he must necessarily not be lurking. What. Do you know how easy it is to log out of the boards and still be very actively reading the thread and even writing your posts? It is so easy. I’m not saying “lynch Rat” – dude’s an Aussie, after all – but that is a specious reason to wave away suspicion.
Honestly, I never thought of that before
I just have my account set to "Log in Forever" so I just kinda assumed people did the same. Never thought of logging out to pretend you're not on. I'll keep that in mind from now on.
Bard makes good points against Alex, and so far, I'm inclined to agree, especially after the roleclaim by Snow. Only problem with a roleclaim in this game is I think we ALL have some kind of little poké power. If not a permanent one, a one shot deal.
Bah, more later. Currently at the start of page 8. I have to run to class now though, so rest of thoughts have to wait.
For now, I'd rather have my vote somewhere rather than no where.
Ahh! Just noticed Snow is minus one to hammer with newest votecount.
##VOTE: SirAlexPeople still seem to be discussing, there's still time left in the day, and I agree with Bard on points against SirAlex. I'll review the rest of the thread upon return in 2 hours, and then see what I think. Its looking like a SnowFire lynch right now though.
P.S., Sorry for what looks like a huge wall of text, but its mostly quotes taking up the space.