When he first posted, I do admit, I was a bit concerned as to why he would do this, and I still disagree that it would have been a difficult thing to hide for long. Easy enough to stick his vote in with a bunch of others, so there could still be speculation as to who exactly was the cause of the anony-vote. At the same time, however, having heard others' arguments on the subject, I've seen that should he have tried to keep it secret, it would have blown up in his face eventually, and (providing he is town) would have been bad for town as a whole.
Ashdla, to touch on why I, and most of the people who think it was prolly a good idea for him to claim when he did, if he did that (sticking his vote in the middle of a bunch so it would be hard to tell whose vote it was) we would have lost precious time arguing about whose vote it was/why they voted/why they tried to hide it (is he scum? third party? why hide if TOWN!?) etc. Having him say up front that it was him shaved off lost time trying to logic out the culprit. I think it has been explained a few times in mafia games before (and has played out in many) which is why I thought I'd mention it since this is your first game.
Yep, thanks QR, like I said in that post, I understand why he did it, since reading people's opinions on why they thought it was a good thing.
Something else I'd like to touch on here are people's comments on my posts lacking content. I'll admit, I'm new to this. While this isn't an excuse by any means, it has taken me a bit to really see how the game is played, and what my posts should contain in terms of opinions and theories. I apologize for having a bit of a slow start, but I think this post, and any following it, should fit the flow of Mafia better.
Now more to the meat of this post.
So apparently, a couple major things happened while I was at work, or at least, they seem major to me and will be what this post is mainly about.
First off, Ciato poofing and Tai taking her place.
I... really feel odd about this. By that I mean, brand new person added is kind of... ugh, hurting my brain. I'm not sure how this'll pan out, and I'd like to see how the game progresses a bit, see Tai's play ect, in order to draw a more conclusive opinion.
Secondly, Snow's roleclaim.
Well I... this seems odd to me. Though my experience is limited, having only half the votes on you needed to lynch isn't really the give up point, is it? Honestly, this is reeking of third party to me, and wanting to get lynched. I say, if he wants to quit anyway, he should do so, and then we can not waste our votes on him. He's perfectly capable of telling Cid he wants out of the game, isn't he? (if that's not the case, I stand corrected) In my opinion, that means we should go for someone who would actually be worthwhile to lynch. Moreover, if he's town like he says he is, then we'd be wasting a lynch on a
town when we could be going after scum. Frankly, I'd like to call your bluff, Snow.
Thirdly, 'this is how *insert person here* always plays!'
I don't really care who this is directed toward, but since I haven't played Mafia before, personally, I'm not going to be taking into consideration who normally plays what way. For me, it wont be an excuse to act any given way. More specifically, yes Meeple, the way you post makes it difficult to understand the main thoughts you're trying to get across. I think something like that was said in Ciato's direction also, but I didn't find it overly distracting in her case. Just wanted to put that disclaimer out there.
Lastly, who I'm voting and why.
For the reasons I've listed above, I'm not going to be jumping in the dog pile to vote for Snow. It seems off to me, as I said. What I do agree with, though, is that the passionate defense Meeple gave Shale, and his jumpy defensiveness in general seems off to me. The way he continued to support Shale and divert attention to those who had targeted him doesn't look very good. Putting such a tangible link between yourself and another player generally isn't a good idea, from what I've gathered. Also, I'd really like him to try is best to format his posts in a way that is easier to read. People easily get put off by huge walls of text, and it might encourage them to skim posts instead of reading them thoroughly as they should. Not wanting people to look too closely at what you're posting also seems scummish, and for those reasons, my vote goes here.
##Vote: Meeple