Cave Story Remix Project - Never Die (Cave Story) vs dasaten - Warring For The Heavens (Seiken Densetsu 3): High Tension Wire is awesome...in the original song. This version was just a worse synthed version...WORSE SYNTH THAN AN SNES SONG IN A REMIX IS NOT FORGIVABLE.
Best of Shape - Battle #5, Photoelectron Mix (Saga Frontier) vs Faye Wong - Eyes on Me (Almighty Mix) (Final Fantasy 8): Whatever.
Sync's Art - Necrofantasia (Perfect Cherry Blossom) vs silent - Final Fantasy 4 Tororian Love Song OC ReMix (Final Fantasy 4): Bad vocals on an FF4 song loses to something that at least sounded decent...pretty badly.
Nintendo Super Famicom Game Music - Ending (Super Mario World) vs Hydain - Figaro Castle (Final Fantasy 6): However, Figaro's theme with vocals...well, they didn't annoy me, and the base song was so much better anyway.
Hellion Sounds - Tsuyoteki (Actraiser) vs Jildon - One Ringed Angel (Final Fantasy 7): ...yeah, I don't care enough about the other song so this wins by default <.<
Disciple of the Mix - In Mem'ry of Sir Anthony (Final Fantasy Tactics) vs Mario & Zelda Big Band Live CD - SUPER MARIO 64 Opening Theme ~ Overworld Theme (Super Mario 64): Another Mario song to drastically causes apathy, hurrah! The FFT song is at least a melody I enjoyed.
S.S.H. - Decisive Battle with the Looking Ones (Metal Max, Final Fantasy 6) vs Vurez - Basilisk Run (Ninja Gaiden): Not seeing the hype for the NG song. That said, this is the considerably worse version of the SSH Decisive Battle, as there's another one that's purely Decisive Battle, same style, and better synthed...whatever, going with Decisive Battle.
XL Project - Fragmented Floor -sense of 6th- (Final Fantasy VI) vs DJ Orange - Harvest Hoedown (Final Fantasy 5): And much as I like Decisive Battle from FF6...no, just...no, its not a song that works AT ALL in a jazz style. At least Harvest was in the proper style and generally sounded pleasing enough.