List Round 1 Week 7: :( No more REPLIIIIIIIIIIIIIIICAAAAAAAAAAA in Light.

[superaielman]

Godlike

Winners:

1. Lady: 15.45
2. Jenna: 14.88
3. False Althena: 13.64
4. Dhaos: 12.5

Losers:

5. Persephone: 12.17
6. Zenon: 10.63
7. Patriarch: 8.9
8. Zack: 8.8

Out:

9. Berle: 8.58
10. Deis: 8
11. Charlton: 7.38
12. Rashidi: 6.67
13. Albedo: 4.17
14. Cyril: 4
15. Riou: 3.63
16. Emily: 1.81

Heavy

Winners:

1. Lassic: 14
2. Velna: 13.6
3. Wugui: 12.90
4. Fei: 11.81

Losers:

5. Daos: 11.5
6. Barbarossa: 10.18
7. Athos: 8.91
8. Ike: 8.86

Out:

9. Saki: 8.1
10. Serge: 7.33
11. Mithos: 6.86
12. Alicia: 6.1
13. Berserk: 5.9
14. Kanon: 5.1
15. Edge: 4.58
16. Adel: 2.54

Middle:


1. Guy: 15.56
2t. Bruiser: 14.25
2t. Nightburn: 14.25
4. Nanaki: 11.45

Losers:

5. Nelis: 11.44
6. Killey: 11
7. Gruga: 9.17
8. Lufia 1 Hero: 8.17

Out:

9. Hippopressor: 7.86
10. Jill: 6.71
11. Rudy: 4.8
12. Blanca: 4.75
13. Vesper: 4.7
14. Kraken: 3.2
15. Argilla: 3
Disqualified: Duster (6.5)

Light

Winners:

1. Aisha: 14.5
2. Estella: 14.25
3. Frank: 12.57
4. Colette: 11.86

Losers:

5. Mallow: 11.71
6. Kid: 11.23
7. Vitali: 10
8. Lunn: 9.63

Out:

9. Funguy: 8.42
10. Cyan: 6.75
11. Rennac: 6.43
12t. Randi: 5
12t. Asch: 5
14. Lucia (SH2): 4.43
15. Lucia (EBC): 3.13
16. Nara: 2.63

Godlike:

Myria (BoFs)
Cloud of Darkness (FF3)
Loki (VP1)
Royce (Lunar:SSSC)
Tir McDohl (Suikos)
Luis Virgil (XS1)
Mewtwo (PKMN)
Van Grants (TotA)
Lambda Zellweger (WA4)
Naesala (FE9)
Rhapthorne (DQ8)
Ice Queen Avril (WA5)
Repede (ToV)
Xenobia (Lunar:EBC)
Teepo (BoF3)
X-Death (FF5)

Heavy:

Baofu (Pers2)
Freyjadour Falenas (S5)
Jerin (Lufia 1)
Lede (FFT)
Cress Albane (ToP)
Neclord (Suikos)
Gau (FF6)
Georg Prime (Suikos)
Zeno (BoF5)
Lyon (S5)
Lady Harken (WA1)
Solo (DQ4)
Galcian (SoA)
Jack van Burace (WA1)
Lang (LoL2)
Surt (VP1)

Middle:

Noa (LoL1)
Lich (FF1)
Max (SF1)
Fiora (FE7)
Starraptor (PKMN)
Mog (FF6)
Iga (AtLC)
Mizuki (S4)
Adell (Disgaea 2)
Fred Maximillian (S3)
Lexis Shaia (Lufia 2)
Teddie (Pers4)
Jibril (SO2)
Cleo (S1)
Lise (SD3)
Kletian Drowa (FFT)

Light:

Judith (ToV)
Rude (FF7)
Cinnamon (MMXCM)
Kahn (BoF4)
Shana (LoD)
Rozalin (Disgaea 2)
Roger S. Huxley (SO3)
Kahn (S2)
Chansey (PKMN)
Nanami (S2)
Franz (S3)
Saradin (OB)
Ilyana (FE9)
Mint Adenade (ToP)
Starky (CC)
Ruphrect (SO2)

[superaielman]

Godlike:

1. Myria- Myria 3! Still on top.
2. Repede- I'll listen to arguments about holes in gale dog, but as is he works here.
3. Royce- Field is not good.
4. Virgil
5. Van
6. Tir
7. Mewtwo
8. Lambda
9. Naesala
10. Xenobia
11. Rhapthorne
12. Loki
13. Teepo
14. X-Death- Is still a stupid fucking tree.


Heavy:

1. Galcian- Awesome! Until he runs into someone who blocks thunder and ID both.
2. Lyon- Nasty.
3. Lede- Brutal status fighter. Hates bosses.
4. Gau-  Effective all around.
5. Solo- Plenty of good defensive strategies.
6. Lang- Also very solid.
7. Georg- Mdef holds him back.
8. Jack- Solid all arounder.
9. Freyjadour- Competent enough.
10. Neclord- Bland but effective.
11. Jerin- Mirror is nice, but it also all she has.
12. Zeno- fairly competent boss.
13. Surt- VP1 endgame boss.
14. Harken- WA1o

Middle:

1. Lich- Just very good.
2. Noa- Charm+speed.
3. Max- Damage and durability.
4. Fiora- See Max, but with less kneejerk respect.
5. Lexis- Hard to crack his defensive game without status or very good damage.
6. Mog- See Lexis, except he is a slow starter.
7. Fred- Defense/evasion.
8. Adell- Evasion!
9. Lise- Silence plus stat downs. Good field though.
10. Iga- Kneejerk.
11. Mizuki
11. Teddie- Good game overall, but such a slow starter.
12. Jibril- He eats people! Sucks at everything else.
13. Kletian- Offense is good! The rest isn't.
14. Cleo- Don't give her the fire rune.  

Light:

1. Cinnamon- Fairly solid.
2. Shana- Doesn't OHKO much in light, but also doesn't matter too much?
3. Starky- why
4. KahnBoF- *sob*
5. Rude- Boss
6. Chansey- Good defensive game at least.
7. Judith- spoils some elemental mages.
8. Saradin- Weird antimagic spoiler. Could be lower.
9. Rozalin
10. KahnS2- Think his healing gets him this far.
11. Nanami- She's okay enough.
12. Franz- Slowish 3HKO with magic and some tankiness.
13.  Roger- Burn in hell.
14. Ruprehct- Scrub wiseman.  
15. Ilyana- Doubled by average, .5 PC HP to physicals before that. Holy balls.

[Dark Holy Elf]

Godlike:

1. Myria (BoFs)
2. Loki (VP1): Possible I'm overrating his HP, but yeah.
3. Cloud of Darkness (FF3): Weakest of the champs, but still champ.
4. Mewtwo (PKMN): Pretty psycho.
5. Royce (Lunar:SSSC): Slow might-as-well-be-death and OHKO off boss HP.
6. Tir McDohl (Suikos): Fast death and OHKO works.
7. Luis Virgil (XS1): Limit boss with status nonsense, works.
8. Van Grants (TotA): Limit bosses need a bit more HP than this to be good.
9. Ice Queen Avril (WA5): Needed frue 4D Pocket for awesomeness.
10. Lambda Zellweger (WA4): Interesting.
11. Xenobia (Lunar:EBC): Better Jecht can at least hang in the division.
12. Naesala (FE9): Better durability than I used to think, but still nothing special.
13. Rhapthorne (DQ8): Timbrel of Tension + Uber Call Team = your HP blows.
14. Teepo (BoF3): Could just as easily be Heavy?
15. X-Death (FF5): Downgrade.

[Taishyr]

Godlike:

1) Myria (BoFs) - Mmmyep. Myria3 for PCs, Myria1 for bosses (Godlike PCs tend to have the healing (tend) to outslug Myria1.)
2) Loki (VP1) - ...yeah, probably? But the respect's not high, here.
3) Mewtwo (PKMN) - Psycho kitty with, at this point, three forms I consider legal. Granted, first is still best, usually. But there might be niche uses for the other two.
4) X-Death (FF5) - Fuck it, I allow the castle form. Which is the only thing he has worth a damn to me, but it -is- startlingly competent. Still, anything not-physical slugging is a limit and I don't respect the speed (so he gets average), so PCs have time to buff up and bosses... well, against bosses, he's possibly one of the scarier fighters with that form. And I'm okay with that. Tree hype can burn, though, and I'm fine with anyone tossing him at bottom. <_<
-- um... drop --
5) Royce (Lunar:SSSC) - Even if I'm not 100% sure I see Shoot Lancer as an OHKO, it's pretty close. DOES NOT LIKE ME FOR MY INTERPS, but isn't a bad boss slugger still. Castle XDeath -- (lacks the variety at lower HPs, is slower, isn't as magically tanky).
6) Tir McDohl (Suikos) - Hi. *ZOT*
7) Lambda Zellweger (WA4) - Another boss who hates my interps - more PCs, more people to hit him. Then again I actually have something resembling durability respect for him so he might take a hit or two?! (not in Godlike) Still, the speed and damage lets him take out a lot of bosses, which are the standard fare.
8) Xenobia (Lunar:SSSC) - Lowish 2HKO MT for the PCs or a ST status hit/physical, sluggish but durable... eh. Crummier of the sisters.
9) Rhapthorne (DQ8) - Huh, accidentally deleted him. I ... don't see Timbrel as legal here (still confused as to how you get it before aftergame, even; that was the earliest I even had the pieces for it, but I accept I wasn't optimal at alchemy) but neither do I have that much respect for the damage. The durability kinda blows to me even without Timbrel, that AI was pretty bloody bad.
10) Cloud of Darkness (FF3) - FF3o for me as of right now; need to get back to FF3DS. Decent slugfester but can't really take long fights. Kinda a Myria--. Still a low Godlike, though.
11) Teepo (BoF3) - Has durability and um and um. .. And um. >_>


Heavy:

1) Lede (FFT) - Right, she's the good one. Sure, here you go.
2) Baofu (Pers2) - Status locks with his basic physical (Gougasha, 85% freeze odds + competent damage), mocks physicals to scorn, walls Holy/Dark outright, can buff and then lay smackdown with Maka Kaja -> Baptism By Thunder. My interps allow him to use Adrammalech or Barbatos if he runs into a Lightning mage (both Hanged Man Personas) but yours may not. Potential Heavy champ, can't compete in Heavy though - speed is his main failing.
3) Gau (FF6) - Versatility is king. Also gets the Dueling Mask from me for added "...what".
4) Lang (LoL2) - Equip choices of the gods plus magic plus limit range plus killer limit. Solid all around set.
5) Zeno (BoF5) - Tanky, damaging. This works.
6) Lyon (S5) - Pretty much same dueler as Prince, trading healing and durability for turn-based speed and ID. I value the ID threat more, so here she goes.
7) Jerin (Lufia 1) - Can mock a ton of duelists, but doesn't like anyone that can duck her tricks.
8) Solo (DQ4)
9) Georg Prime (Suikos) - Slugfester! ... that's it! (S5 only, btw)
10) Cress Albane (ToP) - Spoiler.
11) Freyjadour Falenas (S5) - Yup. This being said...
--DROP--
12) Jack van Burace (WA1) - Tricksy, but it doesn't save him.
13) Neclord (Suikos) - Don't respect this dude either, and taking Tal/MC interps doesn't help.
14) Lady Harken (WA1) - WA1o. She was a scrub. Working on WA:ACF, tho.


Middle:

1) Noa (LoL1) - Speedy charm, big bang of damage, generally a frightening opponent.
2) Mog (FF6) - Status him, bring magic he doesn't wall, or be mocked out of the arena by a dancing moogle.
3) Lexis Shaia (Lufia 2) - Uh, sure.
4) Mizuki (S4) - Speedy 2HKOer; it's good enough to spoil some stallers and keep the pressure on a lot of other duelers.
5) Lich (FF1) - Still a solid slugfester, but Hold losing its grip against 4 PCs doesn't help his cause too much.
6) Fred Maximillian (S3) - Killing him physically's about as mockable conceptually as killing Mog physically, but he lacks the tricks or walling of other elements, instead just having semicompetent damage. Eh.
7) Cleo (S1) - Relatively speedy, relatively damaging, but mono-elemental and not too hot of an elemental to rely on at that.
8) Starraptor (PKMN) - Intimidate + Growl + Agility + Sky Attack are probably enough to spoil a lot of fighters Staraptor would run into. Runs screaming from any mage, especially any lightning mage. Eh... here works.
9) Teddie (Pers4) - Staller! Hopes you don't have lightning! Is kinda bad at the stalling thing, but gets a second shot so crits aren't a big factor.
10) Lise (SD3) - Spoils silenceable mages, has decent buffing games but they're kinda eh.
11) Kletian Drowa (FFT) - Okay. I give some support respect, I don't view assassination bosses as infinitely frail, etcetera. This being said the durability's just not good enough here.
12) Jibril (SO2) - What's that, Jibril? You don't like how swallow isn't instaloss when more than one PC's on the field? Tough shit~!

Fiora (FE7) - Never used her.
Iga (AtLC) - AtL1, he's somewhere near the bottom but I can't accurately recall where.


Light:

Rude (FF7)
Cinnamon (MMXCM)
Kahn (BoF4)
Shana (LoD)
Roger S. Huxley (SO3)
Chansey (PKMN)
Franz (S3)
Saradin (OB)
Mint Adenade (ToP)
Starky (CC)
Ruphrect (SO2)

what the christ this can wait until later

[OblivionKnight]

Godlike:

7. Tyr (BoFs)
4. Cloud of Darkness (FF3)
5. Loki (VP1)
6. Royce (Lunar:SSSC)
16. Tir McDohl (Suikos)
11. Luis Virgil (XS1)
15. Mewtwo (PKMN)
3. Van Grants (TotA)
12. Lambda Zellweger (WA4)
13. Naesala (FE9)
2. Rhapthorne (DQ8)
10. Ice Queen Avril (WA5)
14. Repede (ToV)
8. Xenobia (Lunar:EBC)
9. Teepo (BoF3)
1. X-Death (FF5)

Heavy:

11. Baofu (Pers2)
15. Freyjadour Falenas (S5)
10. Jerin (Lufia 1)
16. Lede (FFT)
6. Cress Albane (ToP)
5. Neclord (Suikos)
12. Gau (FF6)
13. Georg Prime (Suikos)
2. Zeno (BoF5)
14. Lyon (S5)
3. Lady Harken (WA1)
8. Solo (DQ4)
4. Galcian (SoA)
9. Jack van Burace (WA1)
7. Lang (LoL2)
1. Surt (VP1)

Middle:

Noa (LoL1)
Lich (FF1)
Max (SF1)
Fiora (FE7)
Starraptor (PKMN)
Mog (FF6)
Iga (AtLC)
Mizuki (S4)
Adell (Disgaea 2)
Fred Maximillian (S3)
Lexis Shaia (Lufia 2)
Teddie (Pers4)
1. Jibril (SO2)
Cleo (S1)
Lise (SD3)
Kletian Drowa (FFT)

Light:

Judith (ToV)
4. Rude (FF7)
Cinnamon (MMXCM)
1. Kahn (BoF4)
Shana (LoD)
Rozalin (Disgaea 2)
Roger S. Huxley (SO3)
Kahn (S2)
Chansey (PKMN)
Nanami (S2)
Franz (S3)
Saradin (OB)
2. Mint Adenade (ToP)
Starky (CC)
3. Ruphrect (SO2)

[BaconForTheSoul]

Godlike:

1. Myria (BoFs)- Myria
2. Mewtwo (PKMN) - Speedy, buffing game, solid damage, and I see him as ID immune.
3. Rhapthorne (DQ8) - OHKO damage and I respect the durability more than most.
4. Loki (VP1) - Durable, decent 2HKO damage
5. Cloud of Darkness (FF3) - 2HKO damage and all that, would be better if Cloud wasn't scaled against only Sage/Ninja damage.
6. Tir McDohl (Suikos) - Blast with massive damage and hope it works!
7. Lambda Zellweger (WA4) - Fun trick, absolutely sick speed, but wants actual damage.  (Is fine with the HP since he won't die till turn 3 anyway.)
8. Royce (Lunar:SSSC) - Better Xenobia
9. Luis Virgil (XS1) - Some tricks, but not all that awesome in Godlike
10. Teepo (BoF3)- Kinda like Xenobia, just feels a bit better
11. Xenobia (Lunar:EBC) - Lower tier Godlike
12. X-Death (FF5)- LOL X-Death

Heavy:


1. Lede (FFT) - Tricks work in Heavy
2. Gau (FF6) - More random tricks work in Heavy too
3. Jerin (Lufia 1) - Textbook decent heavy
4. Georg Prime (Suikos) - Nothing special, but limited field for me to vote on
5. Neclord (Suikos) - Flipped a coin with Surt
6. Surt (VP1) - Not too impressive in any aspect

Middle:

1. Lich (FF1)- Good damage, decent durability, some status.  Works well in middle.
2. Mog (FF6) - Most middle lack the damage to beat Mog without good status, which most lack
3. Fiora (FE7)- Speed/Evade works well
4. Lexis Shaia (Lufia 2) - Fun tricks!
5. Mizuki (S4)- Textbook middle
6. Fred Maximillian (S3)- Textbook middle
7. Adell (Disgaea 2) - Not a good middle, but not fail like those below
8. Jibril (SO2) - Nom nom nom
9. Kletian Drowa (FFT) - FFT fail borderline light
10. Cleo (S1) - Suikoscrub should be in light

Light:
Do this in a bit  (I numbered them already, but they're not actually my votes.)

1. Rude (FF7)
2. Kahn (BoF4)
3. Shana (LoD)
4. Rozalin (Disgaea 2)
5. Kahn (S2)
6. Chansey (PKMN)
7. Nanami (S2)
8. Franz (S3)
9. Saradin (OB)
10. Starky (CC)
11. Ruphrect (SO2)

[Lance]

Godlike
1.) Myria (BoFs)
2.) Cloud of Darkness (FF3)
3.) Loki (VP1)
4.) Royce (Lunar:SSSC)
5.) Mewtwo (PKMN)
6.) Naesala (FE9)
7.) Luis Virgil (XS1)
8.) Ice Queen Avril (WA5)
9.) Xenobia (Lunar:EBC)
10.) Van Grants (TotA)
11.) Rhapthorne (DQ8)
12.) Tir McDohl (Suikos)
13.) Lambda Zellweger (WA4)
14.) X-Death (FF5)
15.) Teepo (BoF3)

Heavy
1.) Lede (FFT)
2.) Zeno (BoF5)
3.) Galcian (SoA)
4.) Solo (DQ4)
5.) Lyon (S5)
6.) Georg Prime (Suikos)
7.) Jack van Burace (WA1)
8.) Surt (VP1)
9.) Jerin (Lufia 1)
10.) Freyjadour Falenas (S5)
11.) Cress Albane (ToP)
12.) Lady Harken (WA1)
13.) Neclord (Suikos)

Middle
1.) Mog (FF6)
2.) Max (SF1)
3.) Adell (Disgaea 2)
4.) Fiora (FE7)
5.) Lise (SD3)
6.) Lich (FF1)
7.) Kletian Drowa (FFT)
8.) Teddie (Pers4)
9.) Mizuki (S4)
10.) Lexis Shaia (Lufia 2)
11.) Cleo (S1)
12.) Fred Maximillian (S3)
13.) Jibril (SO2)

Light
1.) Kahn (BoF4)
2.) Rozalin (Disgaea 2)
3.) Rude (FF7)
4.) Ruphrect (SO2)
5.) Chansey (PKMN)
6.) Franz (S3)
7.) Saradin (OB)
8.) Cinnamon (MMXCM)
9.) Ilyana (FE9)
10.) Kahn (S2)
11.) Starky (CC)
12.) Nanami (S2)
13.) Roger S. Huxley (SO3)
14.) Mint Adenade (ToP)

Edit: Now with 100% more Ilyana.

[Random Consonant]

Godlike:

1. Loki (VP1) - Respect isn't high but still works.
2. Mewtwo (PKMN) - Also works
3. X-Death (FF5) - Castle X-Death.
4. Tir McDohl (Suikos) - Sure.
5. Royce (Lunar:SSSC) - Eh.
6. Xenobia (Lunar:SSC) - Eh.

Heavy:

1. Lede (FFT) - Yep
2. Baofu (Pers2) - Yeah, I allow personas from his starting arcanum.
3. Gau (FF6) - Not really sure how I feel about the charm but still has too much shit.
4. Neclord (Suikos) - Kneejerk?
5. Jerin (Lufia 1) - Has some neat tricks.
6. Solo (DQ4) - Also has neat tricks.
7. Cress Albane (ToP) - Is decent.
8. Jack van Burace (WA1) - Meh.
9. Georg Prime (Suikos) - Suiko2
10. Lady Harken (WA1) - WA1o

Middle:

1. Noa (LoL1) - Tough Love
2. Max (SF1) - Sure.
3. Fiora (FE7) - Sure.
4. Lexis Shaia (Lufia 2) - Half filled IP bar helps a bit, yeah.
5. Lich (FF1) - Solid enough I guess
6. Mog (FF6) - Wishes his stuff didn't take so long to get going but hey tank.
7. Cleo (S1) - Sure, solid stats + fire rune option.
8. Lise (SD3) - Owning mages is worth something, yeah.
9. Starraptor (PKMN) - Well, Lightning/Ice weakness is a bitch but hey Intimidate/decent offense/buffing
10. Iga (AtLC) - IIRC he had a Weak Enemy-like move that took a turn to set up but hey, this is a tough field.
11. Kletian Drowa (FFT) - Durability woes/not great speed/silenceable.  Still can mess you up if he gets a turn but.
12. Jibril (SO2) - Wiseman scrub.  

Light:

1. Shana (LoD) - Sure.
2. Starky (CC) - uhhh
3. Kahn (BoF4) - uhhh
4. Kahn (S2) - uhhh
5. Chansey (PKMN) - uhhh
6. Nanami (S2) - uhhh
7. Rude (FF7) - Not really sure how I feel about these 6.
8. Saradin (OB) - OB64 form is bad IIRC without row changing.
9. Mint Adenade (ToP) - asdf
10. Ruphrect (SO2) - jkl;

[superaielman]

Added the 16th light, since I forgot to replace Soldier.

[Dhyerwolf]

1 X-Death- Castle XDeath is good. This field isn’t great!
2 Loki. Pdur and OHKOs
3 Myria. Myria 3 has nice durable, but not much beginning damage
4 Cloud of Darkness
5 Virgil- Status+Some Durability+Some Slugging Kind of
6 Tir- Damage+Status+Speed
7 Van- Limits+Some durability
8 Royce- Great on everything exc ept speed
9 Lambda- Weirdo
10 Rhapthorne- Okay all arounder
11 Avril- Held back by some elemental wallability
12 Mewtwo- Doesn’t like being held to FRLG (Losing the ID immunity in addition to worse buffing and Mdur!)
13 Xenobia.
14 Naesala. Yep
15 Teepo. Eh sure

1 Harken- 1.5 or so PC HP, OHKO at half HP, anti-physical measures. Yeah, low Godlike here
2 Lede- Solid damage+not bad HP (for an FFT boss)+great at PC killing
3 Lang- Durability, speed, equips, magic and physicals, draining, some status, limits. Lots of lots of versatility.
4 Surt- OPB Heal off solid durability is great
5 Baofu- Sure, having solid weapon status would work round him out really well. Near the bottom without it.
6 Gau- Really hard to kill
7 Zeno
8 Georg
9 Solo- Uh…well rounded
10 Lyon- Speed, damage, status
11 Galcian
12 Jack
13 Cress- Honestly, 7-13 are all really close. Did a lot of gut reacting
14. Prince- Slow, average durability doesn’t work all that well with the healing. Equips and damage are nice, but it’s a solid field and he’s never overly impressed me.
15. Neclord- Gutting here. Speed is bad, HP is…not far from PCish either way. 2HKOs with magic backup, but just a bit underwhelming. Still looking at solid low Heavy though.

Middle
1. Noa- Heavy
2. Mog- Lots of types of physical walls in this field! But…Mog’s combo of wall+some healing+FF 6 equips feels like it makes him the winner
3. Fred- Speedy damage, absurd evasion, has the option of status immunity to me (Albeit…S3 status immunity, which misses fatal stuff)
4. Lexis- Healing->Some evil limit status works well
5. Iga- HP+Cure All+Cure+Amaidar Fist. 3.5 area here, I think.
6. Lich- 6-12 is generally awesome. Lich…hates fast Fire mages, slow Fire mages that block Paralysis…but spoils physicals, 2HKOs, solid status
7. Cleo- Fast 2HKO+solid other stats. Spoilable
8. Max- 2HKO at marginally above average speed+good stats. Eh…maybe this should be below Adell, but…
9. Adell- Lots of HP, 2HKOs. Accuracy is not good, but evasion…is, and his evasion applies to all damage. Sure.
10. Mizuki- Fast near 2HKO that’s ITE+solid other stats. Not so spoilable, but doesn’t have Cleo’s normal damage punch (or ability to get around Pdur)
11. Teddie- Few neat tricks, although cast worst at taking advantage of the Auto armors I think
12. Jibril- Solid 2HKO, although not OHKOing too much (Albeit a few things)
13. Fiora- Tanks res, otherwise…evasion that isn’t enough for me to really respect and stats that are okay.
14. Lise- Not really sure here. She’s not near the top I’m thinking, but without knowing the actual potency of effect on her defensive buffs, can’t really say. Assuming they aren’t great, she’s riding on Silence often (Otherwise feels like an averagish slugger)
15. Kletian- Could be underrating him, but I feel like that his HP is probably just below the zone where his smash strategy works (And his damage isn’t enough to grab the OHKO often enough and his speed isn’t potent enough and he hittable by Silence!). Not bad, but too flawed overall I think.

Light:
1 Kahn (BoF 4). Middle
2 Cinnamon. Solid borderline
3 Rude. Headache. This works.
4 Roger. Some status, some MP damage, some durability. Not great, but this pool…
5 Shana. Not a lot of damage respect, but she can 3HKO off good speed and play a few other games too.
6 Franz. 2HKO (albeit sloooooow) with a solid enough physical backup and durability (….Compared to this field)
7 Kahn (S2)- Some magic, a shot of healing. Eh.
8 Nanami. Fast+Solid stats. Physical damage is probably pretty bad, but eh.
9 Rozalin- Spoils evasion, but that’s really it
10 Starky- Okay CC. Semi spoilable where many of the others aren’t.
11 Chansey- Yeah, has some cute tricks to try to get around the PDur. And then combines them with that speed…Status would work…if it was turn 1.
12 Saradin- That Pdur is fail
13 Mint- Prone to be destroyed by crits or something
14 Ilyana
15 Ruprecht- Beyond horrid

[Cmdr_King]

Godlike:

1. Myria (BoFs)
2. Cloud of Darkness (FF3)
3. Loki (VP1)-  There's... a bit of a gap in this pool, huh.
4. Repede (ToV)
5. Tir McDohl (Suikos)
6. Royce (Lunar:SSSC)
7. Van Grants (TotA)
8. Mewtwo (PKMN)
9. X-Death (FF5)
10. Luis Virgil (XS1)
11. Rhapthorne (DQ8)
12. Lambda Zellweger (WA4)
13. Ice Queen Avril (WA5)
14. Teepo (BoF3)
15. Xenobia (Lunar:EBC)
16. Naesala (FE9)


Heavy:

1. Lady Harken (WA1)
2. Galcian (SoA)
3. Lede (FFT)
4. Zeno (BoF5)
5. Georg Prime (Suikos)
6. Surt (VP1)
7. Solo (DQ4)
8. Lang (LoL2)
9. Lyon (S5)
10. Cress Albane (ToP)
11. Baofu (Pers2)
12. Freyjadour Falenas (S5)
13. Gau (FF6)
14. Neclord (Suikos)
15. Jack van Burace (WA1)- No one really bad in this pool, really.

Middle:

1. Lich (FF1)
2. Cleo (S1)
3. Mog (FF6)
4. Fiora (FE7)
5. Adell (Disgaea 2)
6. Starraptor (PKMN)
7. Mizuki (S4)
8. Jibril (SO2)
9. Fred Maximillian (S3)
10. Teddie (Pers4)
11. Lexis Shaia (Lufia 2)
12. Kletian Drowa (FFT)

Light:

1. Kahn (BoF4)
2. Rude (FF7)
3. Cinnamon (MMXCM)
4. Judith (ToV)
5. Shana (LoD)- I feel like the top five could be rearranged any which way and still look okay to me.
6. Mint Adenade (ToP)
7. Kahn (S2)
8. Franz (S3)
9. Roger S. Huxley (SO3)
10. Rozalin (Disgaea 2)
11. Nanami (S2)- and 7 through 11 are all fairly different, competitive but not champ worthy Lights.
12. Starky (CC)
13. Ilyana (FE9)
14. Chansey (PKMN)
15. Ruphrect (SO2)

[DjinnAndTonic]

Godlike:

1 Myria
2 Royce
3 Repede
4 Mewtwo
5 Van Grants
6 Cloud of Darkness
7 Tir McDohl
8 Loki
9 Ice Queen Avril
10 Rhapthorne
11 Xenobia
12 Lambda Zellweger (WA4)
13 Naesala (FE9)
14 Teepo (BoF3)
15 X-Death (FF5)

Heavy:

1 Lede
2 Baofu
3 Galcian
4 Surt
5 Gau
6 Jerin
7 Jack van Burace
8 Lyon
9 Cless Albane
10 Georg Prime
11 Solo
12 Freyjadour Falenas
13 Lady Harken
14 Neclord

Middle:

1 Noa
2 Mog
3 Max
4 Fred Maximillion
5 Lexis Shaia
6 Lise
7 Lich
8 Teddie
9 Mizuki
10 Adell
11 Iga
12 Jibril
13 Cleo
14 Kletian Drowa

Light:

1 Kahn (BoF4)
2 Judith
3 Saradin
4 Rude
5 Cinnamon
6 Shana
7 Franz
8 Kahn (S2)
9 Nanami
10 Chansey
11 Rozalin
12 Illyana
13 Mint Adenade
14 Starky
15 Roger S. Huxley
16 Ruphrect

[Tide]

Oh god, I can vote on Light. WHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHY?!

Godlike:
1. Loki (VP1) - Not a terribly strong pool, but Loki's pretty solid.
2. Mewtwo (PKMN) - Yeeah. Pretty much reems stallers + limit opponents and can hold his own otherwise.
3. Repede (ToV) - Not completely sold (or rather have that great of a respect) on the Gale Dog strategy myself, but he works for what he is.
4. Luis Virgil (XS1) - Spoils melee fighters + status. Limit helps.
5. Van Grants (TotA) - Well...the only MA I sorta respect is Celestial Elegy. That works somewhat as a HP-1, which is decent enough I suppose.
6. Ice Queen Avril (WA5) - Lack of game winning 4D Pocket drops her yeah. But good speed + 2HKO keeps her afloat.
7. Lambda Zellweger (WA4) - Fun, but doesn't tend to beat the powerhouses. Damage is offset by his high speed, but sometimes not enough in godlike where the uber durable roam.
8. Naesala (FE9) - Eh...FE10 form may be better. FE9 form...well he will double attack often, but...
9. X-Death (FF5) - lol

Heavy:
1. Lady Harken (WA1) - The ice weakness and durability hold her back from Godlike. But...barring that, fast, anti physical, resists other elements, and if you can't solidly 1HKO her, you are going to get absolutely REEMED by Maximum Risk.
2. Lede (FFT) - Great PC killer overall.
3. Lyon (S5) - Fast, damaging, and has a decent variety of options.
4. Gau (FF6) - Very versatile; random actions hold the respect back though.
5. Surt (VP1) - Misremembered him with Barbatos. Mm...2HKO Fire damage, OBP Heal and he has Might Reinforce. Around here, I suppose?
6. Georg Prime (Suikos) - Completely one dimensional, but rips you apart badly if you can't target his M.Dur
7. Jack van Burace (WA1) - I may go by ACF form from now on with all WA characters (makes Cecilia ), which means Jack loses some variety, by gains better ability to do damage...probably rounds him about here.
8. Freyjadour Falenas (S5) - Don't find Freyjadour is that impressive - speed holds him back. And some of his spells are pretty damn useless.

Middle:

1. Fiora (FE7) - Decently fast + decent M.Dur = pretty good with added spoilage potential here. Counters round things out of course.
2. Mog (FF6) - Bring magic or status. Dance isn't terribly reliable nor is his damage, but egads, that raw defense = lol to you if you don't have the things listed up top.
3. Starraptor (PKMN) - Intimidate is pretty good. And Agility + Close Combat/Brave Bird means his damage is pretty good. Weak to common elements though certainly isn't.
4. Teddie (Pers4) - Is a little slow, which means he takes a while to get going and certainly costs him sometimes. 3 Resists though is pretty good, might be worth the 1 weak tradeoff.
5. Kletian Drowa (FFT) - LFT form would be high middle though.

Light:
1. Cinnamon (MMXCM) - Elemental defenses + Hypermode. Pretty good.
2. Rude (FF7) - Eh...Rude...he's not terribly impressive. But this Light pool...
3. Judith (ToV) - Kneejerk.
4. Roger S. Huxley (SO3) - Some MP damage options, status and equip options. Helps more than...
5. Starky (CC) - Lack of equip options hurts some, but he has some chipping potential. Damage could use a little more work, but passable in Light.
6. Chansey (PKMN) - The lack of damage + lack of P.Dur is pretty bad, even if she can hold enemies off with her defensive tools. Still beats...
7. Ilyana (FE9) - -_- at that speed and durability mix. A winner is YOU.

[Monkeyfinger]

Godlike:

Best ranked dueller:
1) Myria (BoFs)

Champ caliber:
2) Mewtwo (PKMN)
3) Cloud of Darkness (FF3)

Pretty good:
4) Lambda Zellweger (WA4)
5) Royce (Lunar:SSSC)
6) Van Grants (TotA)

Mediocre:
7) Luis Virgil (XS1)
8) Tir McDohl (Suikos)

Bad:
9) Loki (VP1)
10) Naesala (FE9)
11) Rhapthorne (DQ8)
12) Xenobia (Lunar:EBC)
13) X-Death (FF5)

Belongs in heavy:
14) Teepo (BoF3)


Heavy:

Very good:
1) Lede (FFT)
2) Zeno (BoF5)
3) Galcian (SoA)
4) Neclord (Suikos)
5) Lyon (S5)
6) Gau (FF6)

Pretty good:
7) Lang (LoL2)
8) Jack van Burace (WA1)
9) Solo (DQ4)

Mediocre:
10) Freyjadour Falenas (S5)
11) Georg Prime (Suikos)

Bad:
12) Surt (VP1)

Middle:

Very good:
1) Lich (FF1)
2) Staraptor (PKMN)
3) Mog (FF6)
4) Fiora (FE7)

Pretty good:
5) Teddie (Pers4)
6) Iga (AtLC)
7) Lexis Shaia (Lufia 2)
8) Max (SF1)
9) Fred Maximillian (S3)

Mediocre:
10) Jibril (SO2)
11) Lise (SD3)
12) Adell (Disgaea 2)

Bad:
13) Kletian Drowa (FFT)

Belongs in light:
14) Cleo (S1)


Light:

Very good:
1) Kahn (BoF4)
2) Roger S. Huxley (SO3)
3) Rude (FF7)

Pretty good:
4) Ruphrect (SO2)
5) Starky (CC)
6) Franz (S3)

Mediocre:
7) Chansey (PKMN)
8) Kahn (S2)
9) Cinnamon (MMXCM)
10) Rozalin (Disgaea 2)

Bad:
11) Nanami (S2)
12) Saradin (OB)
13) Ilyana (FE9)

[superaielman]

I need more votes! *Cracks whip* Also, finish up divisions, etc.

[SnowFire]

Godlike:
** Ubergodlike
1. Repede (ToV) - Okay no ToV but I've seen Repede, and knowing my ARPG interps he's insane, because I see Gale Dog as going off very early in the round.  Loses only to initiative / REALLY FAST OHKOs / Dispelers / maybe Selphie.

**High Godlike
2. Cloud of Darkness (FF3)
3. Van Grants (TotA) - Has problems with evasion but otherwise great.
4. X-Death (FF5) - Yeah I allow NeoExdeath, etc.  If Jecht had a battle form earlier in FFX called "Jecht" I'd still allow "Braska's Final Aeon" as a legal form for DL "Jecht" despite it not entirely being him and having a different name.  Anyway NeoExdeath is Belial.  Have good MT and win, don't and almost always lose horribly.  Buffers can't really get going either - Almagest is coming on turn 3 + Grand Cross on turn 4, so even surviving NeoExdeath's assault doesn't give much time to setup defenses if you can't just unleash an MT OHKO.  Which luckily is quite doable in Godlike.

** Standard Godlike
5. Luis Virgil (XS1) - XS1 form is a quirky status whore, XS3 has got the Break -> crazy damage for bosses that can't OHKO him...  though XS3 form has a nasty elemental weakness too.
6. Loki (VP1)
N/A. FE9 Naesala's boss form.
7. Royce (Lunar:SSSC)
8. Myria (BoFs) - Myria1 scaled against Agni (well, maybe not all Agni, but mostly).  Still ridiculous durability, but bad damage.
9. Rhapthorne (DQ8) - Eh, respect his durability more than others due to not really holding Call Team against him.
10. Tir McDohl (Suikos)

** Low Godlike
11. Naesala (FE9)
12. Xenobia (Lunar:EBC)

** Low Heavy
13. Lambda Zellweger (WA4) - Actually had I been around at the time I'd have voted DNR for Lambda, really.


Heavy:

** Heavy/Godlike
1. Lyon (S5)
2. Lede (FFT)

**Heavy
3. Solo (DQ4)
4. Freyjadour Falenas (S5)
5. Georg Prime (Suikos)
6. Jack van Burace (WA1)
7. Galcian (SoA) - Galcian is a bit of a pet peeve of mine.  He translates WAY too good to the DL since he's a Puny in-game.  He deserves some kind of DL punishment for this but I'm not sure what's fair aside from not respecting his HP much.  Sigh, boss status immunity + some durability + ID still go far, though.

** Low Heavy

8. Lady Harken (WA1) - Honestly I barely remember any WA1 boss, they all kinda couldn't threaten you in-game and strike me as Middles.  Kneejerk entirely here since apparently she's better on paper.

** Middle
9. Gau (FF6) - Only starting rages.
10. Neclord (Suikos) - LOL Neclord.

Middle:

Eh whatever.  I'll just say that Starraptor (PKMN) strikes me as more a Low Heavy than a High Middle - Brave Bird + Quick Attack is pretty brutal at wiping out most PCs and only giving them a single turn to work with.  And against those slower, Brave Bird + Aerial Ace or 2 Aerial Aces.  Endeavor + Quick Attack might have some occasional merit as well.  Maybe I'm overselling his damage.