Zog (BoF1) vs Loki: Indiscriminate really hurts, here.
Zog vs Chris Lightfellow: SL chains and healing until doubles between them probably works, yeah.
Zog vs Xenobia: Faster. Zog shouldn't win matches with this.
Zog vs Kurando Iungami: I doubt Kurando has the resources for this. Maybe if his best damage were magic.
Zog vs Luis Virgil: I think?
Zog vs Ghaleon: Chaos Shield largely walls Zog, whose doubles are infrequent.
Zog vs Empyrea: Probably 2HKOs with Gale or something silly. 3 at worst. Empyrea has the wrong damage type, here.
Zog vs Lenneth Valkyrie: Both forms probably handle this, fire res + turnless healing, or two-round.
Zog vs Ted: 1.5x parasitic healing gives Ted the extra push he needs, since I see him just missing the 2HKO.
Zog vs False Althena: 3HKOs, sure as heck isn't 2HKOed or even close.
Luther (SO3) vs Loki: Probably just one-rounds him. Maybe not, but Luther has the wrong damage type here anyway.
Luther (SO3) vs Chris Lightfellow: Some status or other.
Luther (SO3) vs Xenobia: Can tank two turns of evil Luther damage and two turns of crappy Luther damage.
Luther (SO3) vs Kurando Iungami: 2HKOed by weak + strong, can't get doubleturns.
Luther (SO3) vs Luis Virgil: Gut says the better durability pushes him through.
Luther (SO3) vs Ghaleon: If Xenobia could win this...
Luther (SO3) vs Empyrea: Physical tankiness to the rescue, I think.
Luther (SO3) vs Lenneth Valkyrie: Uncertain.
Luther (SO3) vs Ted: Boomies.
Luther (SO3) vs False Althena: Ow.
Zog 4-6
Luther 2-8
Wouldn't have pegged Zog as the better Godlike offhand, though the pool didn't really play to Luther's strengths.