Godlike:
Scias (BoF4) vs Lamington (Disgaea): Scias can resist Judgement but he's still 2HKOed by a physical (crit + non-crit even) so he only makes headway on doubleturns or if he evades (15%... though Lamington is accurate so probably lower). He's partly ITD which helps, but he still only has the MP for ~13 useful actions (Rejuvenate or Shining Blade) which just isn't enough, I think.
Brahms (VPs) vs Profound Darkness (PS4): VP2 Brahms... although VP2 Brahms didn't exist then, so which do I vote on? VP2 loses pretty obviously. VP1... still loses. He only wins with the following combination of factors: (a) You don't do HP buffering at all [even partial HP buffering which I do saves her], (b) you see him surviving a Shadowbreath, (c) you see him fragile enough to be 2HKOed by Flamebreath so that he can reach his limit whatever PD does [pretty small window when combined with the previous], (d) you see him as faster than PD, (e) you view one 25% chance and one 50% chance as good enough to get off Bloody Curse [it's between 50% and 67%, so depends on threshold]. That's a lot of things that have to fall his way.
Heavy:
Alena (DQ4) vs Mazus (S2): Sure, I'll trust Super+Snow enough to not bother mathing this.
Laike (Lunar:SSSC) vs Harle (CC): Abstain on Laike today. Doesn't matter long-term because...
Haschel (LoD) vs Chaz Ashley (PS4): Chaz in Heavy is mean. Probably faster, doesn't matter because he has ID which Haschel doesn't block.
Middle:
Nash Rumack (Lunar:SSSC) vs Cray (BoF4): Cray can resist status by 50% and even block whichever one is most offensive. None of this saves him, he's too slow to kill Nash before Nash does something nasty with sleep or paralysis or ID.
Tengaar (Suikos) vs Vivi Ornitier (FF9): Nulls earth.
Light:
Bowser (SMRPG) vs Noel Chandler (SO2): Fear.
Lezard Valeth (VPs) vs Guile (CC): EDIT: VP2 is legit? Okay then. Spiritual Thorn is go.
Jacques (S3) vs Leon Geeste (SO2): This is close I think? *checks* Oh, guess not.
