Miguel (CC) vs Melfice (G2) - Miguel 2HKOs and isn't 2HKOed back.
Miguel vs Yuri Hyuga (SH1) - At worst (i.e. Yuri goes last), Yuri should lap Miguel post-For Everyone and For Tomorrow until Yuri runs out of MP, finishing with a physical, actually works. Yuri1's pretty well built for these skirmishes. If he goes first, though, this is easier: 2HKO with For The Children. It -barely- works, but.
Miguel vs Yuri Hyuga (SH2) - On the other hand, Yuri2 kinda doesn't like being weak to Holy. Miguel scrapes the OHKO.
Miguel vs Killer (SH3) - Miguel going first kinda seals this. Killer gets two turns at most and can't really win with them. If he gets -OHKOed- (entirely reasonable), this gets even worse.
Miguel vs Reicher (MK2) - Even if Miguel immuned Holy, it wouldn't really pan out: Lightsword Swing unlocks at 75% HP and guarantees Reicher keeps his offense steadily powerful, and he wins durability in a very big gap.
Miguel vs Cecilia Lynn Adlehyde (WA1) - I don't see Holy Dragon Sword being hit by Parasol, but the debuffs are fair game, which already puts a crimp on his offense. So, Quicken, stall, buff on occasional doubles and steadily whittle Miguel down.
Miguel vs Lucian (VP1) - Outsluggery.
Miguel vs Beowulf Kadmus (FFT) - Holy immunity makes Miguel horrible.
Miguel vs Kaus Debonair (OB) - super's near-encyclopaedic knowledge of OB makes me trust him on his judgment here.
Miguel vs Demi (PS4) - That's a lot of pressure, methinks. TurnBlack likely tips the fight here, and if Miguel goes first (don't think that flies, but oh well), he OHKOs clean.
Miguel vs Hect (G3) - I don't think Hect can squeeze in enough damage even if she -does- get a turn.
7-4. I think it's pretty clear where he belongs, even with the Holy reliance. It cost him a match against Beo in this field, but it balanced by handing him the win against Yuri2.
Pirate (Bravely Default) vs Melfice (G2) - Moveblock hits turn two and that turns Pirate into a Light.
Pirate vs Yuri Hyuga (SH1) - Goes first and might well OHKO. Certainly doesn't need to.
Pirate vs Yuri Hyuga (SH2) - Also goes first and can control the match from there.
Pirate vs Killer (SH3) - Goes first and, even if he can't one-round/ID, Attack debuffing ensures he doesn't get OHKOed by Pirate. A two-rounding is a sure thing.
Pirate vs Reicher (MK2) - Dear god, this is ugly.
Pirate vs Cecilia Lynn Adlehyde (WA1) - Both are very similar in speed and whoever goes first wins. Tiebreaking for Ceci as of now (I don't use the Runes average). EDIT: Yeah, by no Runes, Cecilia is - 0.2 SD, Pirate is - 0.26. There we have it.
Pirate vs Lucian (VP1) - I actually suspect that my higher VP averages mean Lucian actually misses the 2HKO post-Defang, which puts the ball in Pirate's court: Shin Smash, Defang, live through a second Lucian turn, Brave-blitz away.
Pirate vs Beowulf Kadmus (FFT) - Survives a blitz and Pirate can't possibly block even all of Beo's match-winning turn one status. That's some spoiling.
Pirate vs Kaus Debonair (OB) - Kaus' fragmented damage hurts him a lot here. He gets one swing in before eating Defang. Then, Shin Smash => Shell Split get him going further. He may well troll for Adrenaline in order to bust his ass down.
Pirate vs Demi (PS4) - He can't OHKO Demi and this is a big problem. Pirate doing heal-locks with the costs on Amped Strike and Double Damage also doesn't work out too fabulously - to make things worse, his basic physical is egregiously bad.
Pirate vs Hect (G3) - I'm fairly sure he's faster.
3-8. That ain't a Godlike. He got mostly slaughtered by the Godlikes - the Heavies were more interesting fights.
Gangrel (FE13) vs Melfice (G2) - Melfice's in that "barely doubles average" range to me. Is that enough to avoid Gangrel's doubling to me? Hmmm, today, yes. Wailing Soul Slash should hit turn two and Gangrel only 3HKOs.
Gangrel vs Yuri Hyuga (SH1) - Goes first, OHKOs and avoids counters. Gangrel can't really deal with that.
Gangrel vs Yuri Hyuga(SH2) - Goes first, uses For Everyone and can control the fight enough for the evade to fail Gangrel.
Gangrel vs Killer (SH3) - Goes first and OHKOs with Vice Blade. Gangrel pdur is appalling.
Gangrel vs Reicher (MK2) - Gangrel likely gets OHKOed by a -single- Remote Mine. This is ugly.
Gangrel vs Cecilia Lynn Adlehyde (WA1) - Gangrel doesn't quite one-round Cecilia (I think it's sensible to see her at 0.93 mdur, which is the minimum needed to survive a Gangrel double), which makes any argument regarding Parasol moot. Ceci could just run Gangrel out of Levin Sword charges if he couldn't wait on his own turn, and she certainly can win this fight in -other- ways.
Gangrel vs Lucian (VP1) - I allow the throne bonuses, so Lucian gets fried by 4x Levin swords.
Gangrel vs Beowulf Kadmus (FFT) - White Robe and Aegis slow Gangrel down way too much. Shock! provides here.
Gangrel vs Kaus Debonair (OB) - Individual hits, individual counters and I THINK Kaus doesn't OHKO Gangrel with a single swipe. I kinda can't buy Debonair surviving a minimum of 4x Levin Swords.
Gangrel vs Demi (PS4) - At the very worst, goes first, Barrier lets her survive a Gangrel attack and then she just runs him out of offense.
Gangrel vs Hect (G3) - Well, if I see Ceci surviving a Gangrel turn, I certainly -do- see Hect doing so as well. If Dhyer's right on his defense evaluations, Hect should be at roughly 0.93 mdur herself, maybe a percent higher.
2-9. And neither is Gangrel. His game is pretty fun, but he really needs to end his fights very fast.
