Bardiche: I'm... mrgh. Not really sure what to say here.
What really bothers me is that, on top of supposedly being cop... you apparently know their exact number and how they are divided up? I guess it isn't impossible in this game, but it seems pretty strange to me that you have all this information about the structure of the scum team. Were you given this information in your opening role PM?
Bleh. You just... haven't felt like much of a townie all game. I'd be more concerned about day two, but, of course, your investigative pattern explains that. Of course, you also land on two of the people I was fairly suspicious about at this point.
So, I'm kind of stuck between a rock and a hard place here. I haven't felt good about you all game, but your role and pattern does explain a decent chunk of my uncomfortableness with you. As it stands... I'm inclined to cut you some slack here.
Ciato: My main problem with you is two-fold. First and foremost, you've had a fairly low presence all game. While you've posted somewhat frequently, very little of it has had any real substance or any real pressure. Of course, we've also had an incredibly crazy day one and a very short day two. Which makes it somewhat forgivable.
It is also worth noting that you went after Yakumo after the whole Eph affair. Not big, but it is there.
Then we have the day two weirdness. And that leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Although you initially agree with me, you feign just wanting to wait to hear from a couple more people. Fine, although the disjunction is a bit obvious considering my concern was him getting to post and potentially daykill someone. The entire point was haste. Then, a few posts later, you do give in and vote for Cappy since town has fairly overwhelmingly decided to lynch him quickly. And you do it wrong.
That's what gets me. You had the power of hammer in your hand and failed to finish the job. That really, really, really looks like a stall job to me. It certainly doesn't help you that Cappy posted a short time later.
Carth: Blar. There are a couple things here bothering me. First and foremost, obviously, your suggestion that both Yakumo/Eph were scum. While this isn't necessarily an unreasonable view, it is something a bit concerning to toss it out there and seemingly encourage that we kill both off. It only further raises my concerns that, in your very next post, immediately bounce off Yakumo, especially since Eph's SMASHing doesn't really seem to clear him. In fact, your initial idea about him going with that "Oh dear, I'm roleblocked forever!" still seems to be quite possible.
Of course, I do kind of wonder why you were so concerned about going after both of them initially since you've revealed your role. Couldn't you have fairly safely tested things with your busdriving, before going after them. At some level, yeah, it all works out given how day one unfolded. At another... it really seems weird to have put so much emphasis on nailing them, especially on day one and especially in light of how it turned out.
Day two, you also had an odd stance on Captain K. You agreed about the dangers with me, but wanted a full claim from him. Like Ciato, it... feels like a bit of a stall? You turn around faster though.
Excal: You... are just weird to me. That last post of yours REALLY bothers me. You vote for Cappy and... make him vulnerable to scum as well? The only reason you would post with those words that you did is because you were assuming that Cappy was scum. Because... well. Obviously, Cappy wouldn't be at the mercy of scum if he were, in fact (and as it turned out), scum. The only way your post makes sense is if you are assuming Cappy was town. In which case your vote against him was weird, because you were voting for someone you believed was town. Admittedly, as an angry, emotional outburst? It makes sense. Sadly, angry emotional outbursts good play does not make. If you really suspected he was town, you weren't much better than him there.
*deep breath* That was a lot of information to digest, but as it stands, Ciato, Carth and Excal are all pinging like mad to me. Bardiche... I obviously have some lingering concerns about him, but I'm certainly not going to press or support his lynching at this moment.
All told... man.
##Vote: Ciato
The slim presence and that weirdness with Cappy on Day 2 is a little too much for me.
