Mrf. Okay, that's something to chew over. Thank you for confirmation of the sticky bomb, at least, Strago.
Thoughts running through my head right now follow this sort of table:
Bardiche T, Carthrat T, Ciato T: We have a cop of dubious sanity, and no good real way to test this without the death of one of the three.
Bardiche T, (Carthrat T, Ciato F or Carthrat F, Ciato T): This is chaos range. Framer/sneakMiller/tons of stuff could be causing this situation.
Bardiche T, Carthrat F, Ciato F: Cop nailed two scum (and spotted the ringleaderperson Cap'n K.)
Bardiche F, Carthrat T, Ciato T: Scum attempting to get one of the two killed. This does not seem beneficial, since there has been a showing from a unknown-aligned nightkiller. Such a trade is... minimal benefit, from what I can see.
Bardiche F, (Carthrat T. Ciato F or Carthrat F, Ciato T): I have no clue on this situation. I don't think it would occur, not without mass confusion?
Bardiche F, Carthrat F, Ciato F: Scum something-or-other defection role/attempting to pull a "reveal two, get the third practically confirmed" situation. Former variant is something Strago seems to be proposing.
My general response? I'm keeping my vote on Carthrat; we haven't seen anything at all that could account for that night 1 kill. There might be, but I would hope someone would come out and say at the least they got a message of a failed nightkill. Since we saw no news of that, I'm sticking with my earlier conclusion; Carthrat was blocked that night, and was supposed to be out killing. Admittedly if you presume Bardiche is not being truthful, the other branch of my attack is lacking, but... I can see no good reasoning around this.
Regarding Bardiche's honestly... waugh. I'm not sure on it and I'm getting tired. Strago has a good point; if this is some massive gambit we're in trouble, but... looking at the list again, specifically the Fs...
B F, Rat T, C T: Bardiche gets Rat or Ciato lynched. Mafia kills the other, unknown ?. Presumably offs Bardiche unless it's scum aligned. If this is the case, kills another townie, 3 t/3 s (B, 2 scum/3 town).
Ignoring 2 F/1 T situations because they make me cry.
B F, Rat F, C F: Bardiche gets Rat or Ciato lynched. Mafia kills either Bardiche if he's ITP or someone else if he's Scumvariant. ITP kills the other of Rat/Ciato, assuming it isn't scum due to EvilTom's death. Down to six again, but with two scum down and one town down.
As a result? I have no clue, and Bardiche is someone I'm not comfortable on either way with this analysis. Going to sleep on it, I will be gone for a long while as a result as I also have class. I will try to make a semi-long post before I go to class but I'm not capable of ensuring this, so as a result don't be surprised if I bloody well disappear for a while again. I request caution on lynches, as usual, and right now I still consider Carthrat and Ciato more suspicious than Bardiche, Carthrat obviously being at the top of my list.