Scott Pilgrim: 0/10. What bullshit. When Scott Patel was defeated he was supposed to drop $2.10 and Ramona offered to lend 15 cents. In the movie, it was 2.30 and 45 cents. This change was inexcusable and represented a complete rape of the source material.
I agree wholeheartedly with Andrew here. Seriously horribly overhyped and awful movie that deserves none of the praise it receives. But, for a deeper evaluation...
The whole premise of the movie is retarded and makes no sense. We're supposed to believe this takes place in Canadia? So where are polar bears? The mounties? The moose? The movie fails miserably at atmosphere - the only part of the movie that makes it feel like it takes place in Canadia is the fact that there's snow on the ground. Way to fail on immersion, movie.
More to the point, there is no logic to this world! The real world? Bullshit. Words appearing instead of sounds? Fucking ridiculous. References to save points and other crazy things? Preposterous! This movie is impossible to take seriously and understand! Where the fuck does this subspace thing come from? How does Ramona carry a gigantic hammer in her purse? This movie makes no explanation or reference to normalcy, making it a failure as a live action movie.
It's also horribly racially insensitive! The first evil boyfriend we meet is Indian. And uses magic. And summons demons. This is horribly insensitive - it perpetuates the stereotype that Indians are evil, godless, magic-using heathens.
And it's insensitive to people with different preferences in other areas! Vegans? Vegans are depicted as also using evil psychic powers, being elitist, and being lying cheats! This is not right! We needed a better, more peaceful and integrative association of Vegans with society, and this movie is simply insulting.
Finally, it also perpetuates some idiotic social interaction - yes, charge into the fray and get slashed, you can come back with an extra life! This movie has so many problems - if only it could have taken cues from the Twilight series, which does a much better job of fashioning fantasy and real life in a believable, and masterful literary and cinematic work.