People ask me to talk, and then they ask me to explain. I do so... and I keep getting asked to explain.
Excal, I voted for you because your vote for me seemed badly placed. You weren't first, you were getting on board with an analysis that wasn't that strong. It's as strong a flinch as I've seen, in my twisted opinion.
The origin of my "mysterious knowledge" was a hunch. Cranbud picked a side in a fight early on, without much discussion or prompting. Rereading it, I said to myself, "this seems like he knows SOMETHING". Thus me downplaying him in my analysis- if he was a cop, I didn't want to be like, "Hey, dood, R you leik a cop or sumthing?" As I explained before, at the time, it didn't occur to me that he could be a scum investigator.
Lastly, my role discussion was at Corwin's request, him not being that familiar with Discworld lore.
Also, frankly, it's very slightly frustrating that the idea of playing a good townie being, when you look suspicious, to write out a will of dying thoughts and lay down in front of a train. Both you and Corwin have lectured me for being "too defensive". Well, a good deal of the discussion has been ABOUT me being so nasty scummy. And as opposed to other conversations that I've been quiet on, I DO have an opinion because I know my alignment 100% as town.
If my tone comes off as harsh, I apologize, it isn't my intent. I have class now.