P3: I still want to punch Ryoji in the face every time I see him.
Almost done with the NG+. Did manage to screw myself out of completing Moon and Fortune, but at least I finished Mitsuru this time (with all of two days to spare). P3 really is ridiculously demanding about full link completion. I think you'd have to answer every single question right, always have a persona of the corresponding arcana when doing link scenes (which is tough the first time through, given persona availability, inventory restrictions, and money concerns) and generally just do everything in the most efficient manner possible. Which would require much advance knowledge of the game anyway. Maybe it's a little easier in FES (I gather you can at least access Moon during vacations there, which would've made enough of a difference for me to finish it here)? But I'm pretty sure anyone claiming they got full completion the first time through P3 vanilla is either a filthy liar or they followed a FAQ very closely.
That, remembering how irritating some of Elizabeth's requests are, and the general shittiness of the plot (in other words, being reminded of everything P4 fixed) mean my rating of the game's going down. I think Soppy's assessment was pretty accurate: if the cast wasn't so endearing, the game would be beyond redemption.
Oh yes, I tried fighting Elizabeth, too. ...Fuck that.