*SPOILERS TO ToV. READ ARE YOU OWN DIGRESSION, ETC. OK. THEY'RE NOT THAT BIG, BUT THEY'RE STILL SPOILERS*
Eh, Alexei's a walking cliche, frankly. The Leader of the Royal Guards who everyone loves and respects is actually EVIL!? NO WAY!!!
I will grant the game does subvert the last crisis regarding him, such that for once it WASN'T part of his plan, but more like he fucked up big time cause he was WRONG about the thing he was releasing.
"Hey, I'm going to unleash this ultimate weapon and TAKE OVER THE WORLD!"
*he unleashes...except its not a weapon, but an object that seals off a BIG EVIL MONSTER*
"...wow, I was horribly wrong..."
Just nice to see a villain be COMPLETELY WRONG about his goals for once, and them spit back in his face. Alexei himself was a lamer, but I will grant the shit he caused being more or less completely by accident in such a way where he goes "oops...I fucked up BIG TIME", and the guy was still an evil prick...yeah...
Duke isn't much better of course. He's another kind of cliche, as in the Well Intentioned Extremist spliced with "Humans Fail at Life and need to die for this world to be saved!" Shame too, cause the scene where he gives you Dein Nomos makes you think twice about him being a jerk, and you just kind of accepting that maybe he's like that cause that's just kind of who he is, and he doesn't actually mean to be a total prick...but the last parts of the game sort of undermine this by securing that no, he's just an anti-social jerk.
Really, I love ToV, but its villain cast is weak. I suppose Barbados or whatever his name was worked for what he was, cause while also a walking cliche, it felt intentional and appropriate here; he's just a temporary antagonist whose obviously not going to be long term. And Yeager's actually genuinely good cause he ends up being different than you'd expect, and it fits in well with the rest of him. But most everyone else is just blech.
Though, I will say that I for one was pleased with how Flynn was an ally pretty much the entire game through. We still got the whole duel that games like this can't avoid, but didn't just pull a forced "Rar, Flynn's Lawful Stupid!" bullshit that you expect to keep him in character but force a fight out, but just a simple friendly duel...one provoked by Yuri no less...and in such a manner that just works well with their friendship. Actually, its nice that Flynn avoids being Lawful Stupid in general; yeah, he's note exactly supporting Yuri's extreme actions...but he still tolerates them enough to let Yuri get away with it, cause they DO have positive impacts!