Dhyer's topic and list and the other tournaments that measure how good a fighter are in depth, a lot of fun to read, without a doubt paint an excellent picture about how good someone is.
They're also painful to vote on thanks to the amount of time required. My idea for this topic's much simpler- Take a random field from a random season, and take four characters who are currently ranked in the division and see how they fare. It gives you a good cross section without tons of voting. I'm also tossing in the actual champ, to see how board opinion meshes with who won that season. Worth a try!
For Godlike, I rolled:
Season 2 Godlike -Celes Chere, Albedo,
Champion- Menardi. Defeated Maxim, Myria, Berle, Songi
This was random, I swear.
Celes (FF6) vs Maxim
Celes vs Myria
Celes vs Berle
Celes vs Songi
Albedo vs Maxim
Albedo vs Myria
Albedo vs Berle
Albedo vs Songi
Menardi vs Maxim
Menardi vs Myria
Menardi vs Berle
Menardi vs Songi