OKAY! Finally.
Here's the long-awaited post
wherein I list folks.
All of these things are
my notes of what I see as
relevant factoids.
-----------------------------
Tai - "Eh." Moves, late, to
Zenny. Sick, irritable,
says the attack on
Smodge had no ground, first.
Tom - Gone for day 1. Agrees
w/me re Smodge, votes.
"Oh no, minus one!"
Then hammers Zenny later.
Votes Tai for lurking.
Is voted on by
Excal, votes for Excal back.
Goes to Smodge later.
------------------------------
Dhyer - L A L
on Zenny, says the Otter
matter is WIFOM,
agrees with QR
but no vote, doesn't say much.
Goes to Smodge. No more.
--------------------------------
Yakumo - Second
vote on Otter, votes for Tom.
Nothing else day 3?
-------------------------------------
Ciato - Says I'm
too aggressive, Smodge plays bad.
Reply 59, she
reacts quite harshly.
First to vote Otter for lurk.
Reply 66,
negates 59
without further commenting.
LOTS of one liners.
Reply 130,
speaks from hypothetical
scum viewpoint. Does this
multiple times in
later posts. 152,
says the Smodge debate
is town vs town,
but can't say why. Is
noncommittal much.
Votes Andrew, reply
173. I find
this post intriguing.
Takes Zenny at word.
Votes me with little comment,
post 239.
------------------------------------------
Meeple - agrees, hops
on with me day 1, then
moves to the Otter.
Says "I'll come up with
something soon." Agrees on Smodge.
Lots of summaries.
Wavers between Smodge
and Excal, then hammers Smodge.
------------------------------------------------------
Andrew - "Hi, I am
lurking, no vote now".
Was unvoted by Otter.
Votes Otter quite late.
"Hammering scum is
good!" (how did you know he's scum?)
Then goes hard on Smodge.
Consistent attack
on Smodge. That's everybody.
Now what does this mean?
First of all, lurkers.
Taishyr, Dhyer, Yakumo,
I have nothing on.
Tai and Yakko both
haven't posted much at all.
Dhyer has said more,
but his posts mostly
are just summaries and such,
and he rarely votes.
Meeple has mostly
been in line with my Smodge hate,
and otherwise quiet.
But Ciato, now,
she sets off my alarm bells.
Simply? Lacks content.
Her first flipflopping,
59 and 66,
was remarked on by
Quietrain, back when
it happened. I found it odd,
but let it go then.
This is one of the
things I did not want to talk
about earlier.
I wanted to see
if she would actually come
out with something thick
before Smodge was lynched,
or if she'd leave her 'case' there.
She left it at that.
All or nearly all
of her posts have been too short,
and lacking content.
Her two line vote post
said I was far too narrow,
but she's not better.
She voiced concern on
Excal, Andrew, and myself,
and thought Smodge not wrong.
Now, Excal was scum,
and her other arguments
have never been backed.
Lots of gut feeling,
lots of "I'll post more later,"
yet nothing later.
She's talked a lot from
scum's viewpoint, which I always
find eyebrow raising.
Also telling, this is
not the way she played back in
the Phoenix Wright game.
There, she attacked me
on intuition (was right),
but then backed it up.
This game feels more like
she's trying to play on that,
and KNOWS who's town/scum.
She definitely
tops my suspect list right now.
So ##Vote: Ciato
I want to hear more,
lots more, from the other three
mentioned. Time to talk!
