Terra (FFs) vs. Sialeeds (S5): S5 art is just better.
Yukari (P3) vs. Touka (Utawarerumono): Yukari is... yeah. Too young-looking for this contest. Not that Touka is much better but at least she has a hint of adult grace.
Ilia (SO1) vs. Kyra (PS4): SO1 needs better art, but she seems more attractive anyway.
Celes (FF6) vs. Rikku (FFX): Isn't 15, or isn't wearing FFX-2 Rikku outfit. Take your pick.
Leanne (FE9/10) vs. Rosa (FF4): Not especially hard. EDIT: Wait, 4DS. Close after all. Coouuuld edit.
Lucia (Lunar2) vs. Cloche (AT2): A little iffy on the Cloche vote based on that shot, because it's not really a great look at her face. Like her garb and overall "look" better, though.
Maria (SO3) vs. Jessica (DQ8): Close enough, abstain.
Sigrun (FE9/10) vs. Melanie (MK): Melanie isn't bad, but I am totally not seeing the greater hype. Sigrun is just super-pretty.
Eleanor (VC) vs. Flannery (PKMN:RSE): I am all for voting against jailbait. Thanks, Cid!
Sarah (S3) vs. Colette (ToS): Colette, guys?
Ouka (SRW) vs. Rydia (FF4): Of the women I haven't seen before here, Ouka is certainly the least attractive in the art posted. That glare does not suit her. Rydia's DS art is pretty good-lookin'.
Jeanne (Suikos) vs. Juli Mizrahi (XS): Close enough, abstain.
Spica (ATs) vs. Aschen (SRW): EDIT: Spica has grown on me. Something about the look, and the outfit is silly, but works anyway.
Avril (WA5) vs. Krane (Generations of Chaos): Yay for posting art! Anyway, Avril is decent, but really nothing more. Krane goes a bit past that... I guess? Actually I'm kinda reconsidering this now. I dunno.
Cecilia Lynn Adelhyde (WA1) vs. Alexia Lynn Elensius (WAXF): ACF to the rescue!
Yukiko (P4) vs. Mercedes (OS): EDIT: Wait, Mercedes is the fairy? Was mixing her up with... gah, I'm blanking on her name, the other non-Gwen woman in the cast. Okay then, this isn't too hard.