Ok time to explain my actions as well as i can.
1. Rat, the gutclaims read them, they were my way of breadcrumbing my investigations, i tried researching previous games but it seems cops have an uncanny knack of dieing early on in DL games, you'll notice each day the first post i have that contains opinions on people is the following
Day 2 (i had Investigated Rat)
Rat - Gut says he is Town, despite staying on the Tom train his posts make sense to me for some odd reason, no reasoning to bac thing up just my gut says something good about him.
Day 3 (I Investigated Gatewalker)
Thoughts on people.
My gut says that Carth is Town, i also have a good feel about gate for some reason, their arguments just seem to make sense to me.
Day 4 (Yakumo was investigated)
There was no post due to IE crashing, it was late (for me) that it crashed and parents were going to send me to bed in 5 minutes so not enough time to do a new post.
I then wake up to see you hammered while i was sleeping.
Day 5 (El Cideon was investigated)
My gut Says Rat, Gatewalker, Yakumo and El Cideon are All town, seeing as my gut is often more accurate than my reasoning i choose to list it here.
As for low post count, i was deliberately lurking at points, although late day 1 and day 4 i was being honest about, why was i lurking? i was the cop, i naturally wanted to stay under the radar of both town AND scum.
End of day 1 i wanted to give Strago a chance to at least roleclaim before i decide on him over Tom so i held my vote.
Day 2 I voted Nitori, he was lurkerish and i disliked the whole Patch/Andrew train and said i found arguments against both of them weren't strong enough for me to vote
Day 3 QR claims cop, naturally i think i'm cop and disbelieve her claim, especially when combined with Taishyr beign a Miller.
Day 4 Corwin VS Nitori, i had liked Corwins posts and thats why i voted for Nitori, i flip-flop end of Day 4 because i was trying to work out whether it was Corwin or Nitori scum by analyzing what we knew of Night 2 Actions, Nitori being a Quackdoc fitted in with the night action, where Corwin ebing a full doc didn't, however i discarded it due to the belief that Chisa couldn't Martyr for Andrew.
That analysis of night 2 actions is here.
Here has what i have been thinking
Hypothetically lets assume Nitori IS a quackdoc
Night 2 would probably look like this (if Andrew is telling the truth)
Chisa Protects Andrew
Mafia target Andrew
Chisa takes the hit.
Nitori "Docs" Andrew
Andrew dodges the kill.
Now here is the Hypothetical where Corwin is the Doc and Nitori the scum
Corwin Targets Andrew.
Chisa Targets Andrew.
Scum Target Andrew with a possible doc buster
Chisa Takes the Docbust
another 3rd party target Andrew?.......
And finally Day 5 with the El Cid issue, i wasn't sure if i was nieve or full cop, Yakumo had turned up Town to me so i believe he was telling the truth about the 1 shot, i was honestly under the impression Cid may be godfather, decided to hold my vote because i need to stand by my investigations until they are proven right/wrong.
This was on day 2 as well. I can't remember what the status of Random Mafia was at this point in the game, but I do know that Alex was *town* in that game; he may or may not have thought Alex was scum at that point but it's really immaterial; he could't be sure. He *couldn't* draw the conclusion that because Alex was acting that way in one game, the action here was likewise scummy. I think it's possible he may have gotten confused (as, of course, were he scum he'd certainly know Alex was scum in THIS game.)
The main argument against Andrew at the time your reffering to Rat, was that he was fishing for Roles, in random mafia Alex accused me of the same and came after me for 3 solid days on it, sure he turned out town, however i could see how scum could abuse the argument that someone is "role fishing" when they aren'tas a way to get a town member killed, this is why i disliked the argument against andrew.
Throughout the entire game he's also been enamoured with roles in general (marvelling at the power of town, listing what roles we know exist... I don't know if it's an attempt at fishing or not, but I do know that without justification, role speculation is *dangerous* because of how tells and such can be dropped in responses to it- at the least.)
Marvelling of course i have been, Tom claimed Cop, QR claimed cop, Tai even mentioned 1 shot of it for memory, also Yakumo claimed 1 shot to, naturally if i'm the damned cop, why are so many people claiming it?, so far we have had more power roles pop up than vanilla's that shows that we had a strong amount of powers under our belts, and that means they're either their seriously flawed or scum have something just as big.
Thoughts on Tonfa later, i'll start reading his posts more in depth.
