Sorry about pretty much ragequitting. I really did lose a giant post at the beginning of Day 2 that sapped my motivation instantly, but it's good to see my instincts haven't gotten completely rusty. My case on Gilgamesh in the original post was more than a one line suspicion toss, plus I think I had Whim pretty much nailed in either one. Of course, this is balanced by the fact that I was utterly certain that Guildenstern was scum up to that point. Wasn't until the voteswitching madness at the end of Day 2 that I began to think townie for him, but I'd already stopped caring and been gj'ed. My bad for not TAKING THE SHOT and shooting Whim when I should have.
It was funny watching people waffle when they had the last two scum pretty much cornered. Meta arguments ruined it, really. Plus the person who came in as Whim was pretty much exactly what was needed. Talked in circles and got everyone confused enough to stop suspecting them. So hat's off to scum. Gumshoe did a great job overall.
Tony wins town MVP though. Impressive voting record, Ciato.
Only person's role I managed to guess was Kilga playing Axem, I think. I guessed Cid for Smithers, Alex for Guildenstern... can't remember who I put otherwise, but I had guesses for most. Took the shotgun approach, basically. Tom for Gilgamesh, Laggy for Gumshoe, I think? No idea.