----Weapons----
Knives: Noemi, Katarine, Ilona, Erastus, Yiu, Eirwen
Light Swords: Katarine, Selena, Shao, Yiu
Guardian Blades: Mirek, Ilona
Large Swords: Isolde, Aurel
Blunt: Rafael, Yiu
Large Blunt: Artur, Aurel
Large Axes: Isolde, Erastus, Jin, Aurel
Scythes: Ilona
Spears: Shao, Claire, Aurel
Polearms: Isolde, Claire, Erastus, Aurel
Staves: Selena, Erastus
Bows: Meilin, Xun
Crossbows: Faulheit, Kasia
Throwing Knives: Faulheit, Yiu
Whips: Kasia, Yiu
Instruments: Jin
Cooking Implements: Eirwen
Universal Weapon Types:
Swords: Swords, Knives, Sabers, Greatswords, etc.
Polearms: Spears, Lances, Javelins, Staves, Pikes, Scythes, etc.
Blugeoning: Axes, Clubs, Maces, Whips, 'Mage weapons' like Tomes, Whips, etc.
Ranged: Bows, Guns, Darts, Shuriken, Handbombs, Slingshots, etc.
Proposed Weapon-type distribution:
(First listed weapon is the unique-type, each of which also falls into one of the above categories)
Noemi: Twin Daggers (Swords), Swords
Erastus: Flails (Bludgeon), Bludgeons
Kasia: Throwing Knives (Ranged), Swords
Shao: Claws/Katar (yeah, those things Kiros uses, classifying them as Swords), Ranged
Fahim: Rings (Ranged), Bludgeons
Aurel: Scimitars (Bludgeon), Bludgeons, Swords (Yes, 3 types)
Isolde: Halberds (Polearms), Bludgeons, Polearms (3 types)
Faulheit: Customized Crossbows (Ranged), Ranged
Katarine: Fencing Swords (Swords), Swords
Claire: Guardian Spears (Polearms), Polearms
Selena: Bo Staff (Polearms), Ranged
Mirek: Guardian Blades (Swords), Swords
Eirwen: Kitchenware (Ladels and Frypans, Bludgeon), Ranged
Artur: Great Hammers (Bludgeon), Polearms
Rafael: Shields (he bashes people with them, Bludgeon), Bludgeons
Ilona: Guardian Scythes (Polearms), Swords
Yiu: Knuckles/Gauntlets (thinking the God-Kings have a solid hand-to-hand fighting style, Bludgeon), Swords
Meilin: Short Bows (Ranged), Ranged, Polearms (3 types)
Xun: Chain-Whips (Bludgeon), Ranged
Jin: Instruments (Bludgeon), Bludgeons
Okay, trying to find a medium between the two for better balancing.
Major Weapon categories:
Slashing
Piercing
Bludgeoning
*Heavy/Light
*Ranged/Melee
*Special
Specified Weapon categories:
*Slashing-Light/Melee
**Knives/Daggers
**Claws/Katars
**Single-Edged Swords
**Double-Edged Swords
*Slashing-Heavy/Melee
**Greatswords
**Scythes
*Slashing-Light/Ranged
**Chakrams
*Piercing-Light/Melee
**Spears
**Halberds
**Pikes
**Rapiers~
*Piercing-Light/Ranged
**Short Bows
**Crossbows
**Darts
**Throwing Knives
**Guns~
*Piercing-Heavy/Melee
**Lances
*Piercing-Heavy/Ranged
**Longbows
**Heavy Crossbows
**Javelins
**Cannons~
*Bludgeoning-Light/Melee
**Staves
**Gloves/Gauntlets/Knuckles
**Axes
**Clubs/Maces
*Bludgeoning-Light/Melee (*Special/Magical)
**Kitchenware
**Instruments
**Shields
*Bludgeoning-Light/Ranged
**Slings/Bolas
**Boomerangs
**Whips
**Flails
*Bludgeoning-Light/Ranged (*Special/Magical)
**Rings
*Bludgeoning-Heavy/Melee
**Hammers
**Great Axes
Consolidating based on cast:
*Slashing-Light/Melee
**Knives/Daggers
**Claws/Katars
**Light Swords/Rapiers
**Guardian Blades (*Special)
*Slashing-Heavy/Melee
**Greatswords
**Scythes
*Piercing-Light/Melee
**Spears
**Halberds/Pikes
*Piercing-Ranged
**Short Bows/Longbows
**Crossbows/Heavy Crossbows
**Darts/Throwing Knives
*Piercing-Heavy
**Lances/Javelins
*Bludgeoning-Light/Melee
**Staves
**Gloves/Gauntlets/Knuckles
**Axes/Clubs/Maces
*Bludgeoning-Light/Melee (*Special/Magical)
**Kitchenware
**Instruments
**Shields
*Bludgeoning-Ranged
**Slings/Bolas/Boomerangs
**Whips
**Flails
*Bludgeoning-Ranged (*Special/Magical)
**Rings
*Bludgeoning-Heavy
**Hammers/Great Axes
That's 23 categories, 5 of which are explicitly 'Special'.
New proposed cast/weapon distribution: (Keep in mind that weapon names separated by a slash are part of the same weapon category.)
Noemi: Knives/Daggers, Light Swords/Rapiers, Greatswords
Erastus: Staves, Axes/Clubs/Maces, Hammers/Great Axes, Flails
Kasia: Whips, Light Swords/Rapiers, Darts/Throwing Knives
Shao: Claws/Katar, Knives/Daggers, Gloves/Gauntlets/Knuckles
Fahim: Rings, Slings/Boomerangs, Staves
Aurel: Greatswords, Hammers/Great Axes, Lances/Javelins, Spears
Isolde: Halberds/Pikes, Spears, Lances/Javelins, Hammers/Great Axes
Faulheit: Crossbows/Heavy Crossbows, Gloves/Gauntlets/Knuckles, Knives/Daggers
Katarine: Light Swords/Rapiers, Axes/Clubs/Maces, Claws/Katar
Claire: Spears, Guardian Blades, Lances/Javelins, Axes/Clubs/Maces
Selena: Staves, Flails, Greatswords, Short Bows/Longbows
Mirek: Guardian Blades, Light Swords, Lances/Javelins
Eirwen: Darts/Throwing Knives, Knives/Daggers, Crossbows/Heavy Crossbows
Artur: Hammers/Great Axes, Greatswords
Rafael: Shields, Staves, Axes/Clubs/Maces
Ilona: Scythes, Guardian Blades, Light Swords, Greatswords
Yiu: Gloves/Gauntlets/Knuckles, Claws/Katar, Light Swords, Axes/Clubs/Maces
Meilin: Short bows/Longbows, Darts/Throwing Knives
Xun: Slings/Booomerangs, Whips, Lances/Javelins
Jin: Instruments, Hammers/Great Axes
By type:
Knives/Daggers: Noemi, Shao, Eirwen
Claws/Katar: Shao, Yiu, Katarine
Light Swords: Noemi, Kasia, Katarine, Mirek, Ilona, Yiu
Guardian Blades: Claire, Mirek, Ilona
Scythes: Ilona
Greatswords: Noemi, Aurel, Artur, Ilona
Spears: Aurel, Isolde, Claire
Halberds/Pikes: Isolde
Short Bows/Longbows: Selena, Meilin
Crossbows/Heavy Crossbows: Faulheit, Eirwen
Darts/Throwing Knives: Kasia, Eirwen, Meilin
Lances/Javelins: Aurel, Isolde, Claire, Mirek, Xun
Staves: Erastus, Fahim, Selena, Rafael
Gloves/Gauntlets/Knuckles: Shao, Faulheit, Yiu
Axes/Clubs/Maces: Erastus, Katarine, Claire, Rafael, Yiu
Kitchenware: Eirwen
Instruments: Jin
Shields: Rafael
Slings/Bolas/Boomerangs: Fahim, Xun
Whips: Kasia, Xun
Flails: Erastus, Selena
Rings: Fahim
Hammers/Great Axes: Erastus, Aurel, Isolde, Artur, Jin
Thoughts?
It makes a pretty distribution at least.