Rate the characters again?

[Dunefar]

We've had a lot of topics on Discussion, ranging the gamut to rating the bad guys, rating in game use, rating the plot and what have you. What we haven't had in years and years is a rate the characters topic, a big old one like we used to have. Is there any interest in doing one of these again? I figure we have enough new people and enough time has passed to make it interesting.

[Ultradude]

I'd vote.

[Taishyr]

That.

[Nitori]

Ko gets Ko/10

[Random Consonant]

Sure, why not.

[Talaysen]

Quit asking about doing it and do it.

Also, we don't need new people to do the topic anyway.  We can, I don't know, USE NEW GAMES FOR ONCE?

[Cmdr_King]

But no one plays new games!

[Crystalgate]

I'd rate, except I'm pretty much out of the loop when it comes to new games. I guess the answer is, yes, but only if I find a full time job soon.

[Talaysen]

I meant new as in games we haven't rated yet.  Seems like every time we do this topic we start with the same X games and then the topic dies and we never get to rate anything different.

[DjinnAndTonic]

That reminds me.... villains topic needs to update~

[Dunefar]

Quit asking about doing it and do it.

Also, we don't need new people to do the topic anyway.  We can, I don't know, USE NEW GAMES FOR ONCE?

Oh yeah, I plan to. I just wanted to see if this was a terrible idea before I go to the effort.

How I'm going to do it is one new game and one old game per session to help get new opinions. I figure I'll start with FF13 since that's brand spanking new.

[Cmdr_King]

FFXIII might be a little too new/inaccessable.  I'd say start with Mana Khemia 2, myself.

[Talaysen]

Agree with CK here.  New is good, but TOO new is bad.  Sucks for those people who do plan to play it but didn't right away.  Pick something a little older than that at least.

[Dunefar]

Sure, works for me.

[Anthony Edward Stark]

Additionally, FFXIII sets an extremely low bar for character scores, or as I like to call them "Sazh and the below-3's."

[DjinnAndTonic]

Start with Soul Nomad.

[Rozalia]

I agree with everyone that new games should bee the ones getting in. Personally though I'd like to see a game like say the Raidou or the Summoner games get in but that isn't happening.

Start with Pokemon HG/SS/G/S/C as a lot of people have played them. May set the bar low but I don't think Pokemon has been done before so it'd be new.

[Dunefar]

I'm going to run with this, thanks for the suggestions all.