Time to Kill was a fine 3D action game as I recall, though the controls were sort of awkward.
edit: it's kind of a shame, but you can't really expect a 14 year old zombie of a game to be much of anything but a horrible mess. Gearbox has the rights to the franchise now, maybe they can make a better game without all that baggage. All the same, ignoring reviews and such until I get my own hands on the game, which hopefully will be soon. Always bet on Duke.