Godlike
Yuri Hyuga (Shadow Hearts Series) vs Hugo Hewitt (Wild ARMs 4): EDIT: SH2 loses decisively after all (frailer than I thought, just gets 2HKOed before he gets a turn). And... I think I vote on SH2 rather than SH1. Not certain here, but for this vote, the fact that it looks like Yuri1 may have lost to Zack seals things for me.
Sanctuary Keeper (Final Fantasy X) vs Cidolfas Orlandu (Final Fantasy Tactics): Orlandu has a 3HKO which becomes a 6HKO after Protect, and also reduces Night Sword to almost nothing. Sanctuary Keeper wins easily if Mana Breath goes through the Aegis Shield, but even if not I'm pretty sure he'll take this, either with Photon Wings (which, as non-typed, definitely goes through) or just tanking and haxing. He's fast enough to avoid the 3-2 which helps.
Heavy
Rofel Wodring (Final Fantasy Tactics) vs Red (SaGa Frontier): Lots of interp calls here, but it definitely favours Red. He wins easily if you don't see Alkaiser moves subject to Defence Up (I do). He wins pretty decisively anyway if RaySword is unbreakable... and it probably is. If you make both calls against Red there then things actually get interesting and deserving of math... but even then Red might win, so yeah.
Flora (The Wizard of Oz: Beyond the Yellow Brick Road) vs Velna (Legaia 2: Duel Saga): Flora may one-round Velna. If not, Velna must one-round back, which is a close thing IF you give Velna both her and her origin's actions every round. I'm not making all three of those judgement calls in her favour.
Middle
Zidane Tribal (Final Fantasy IX) vs Mesarthim (SaGa Frontier): Mesarthim has an answer to everything Soul Blade can do. Blood Chalice stops Doom, Freedom Rune stops both Sleep and Petrify (not that I consider the latter), and REGEN stops any hope Zidane has of winning by confuse or silence (since he has no damage), while Mini does nothing to Mesarthim's nasty skillset. :nelson-laugh:
Light
Mallow (Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars) vs Tita Russel (Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky): Tita's only hope lies in Chaos Brand, but... if the duration is anything near as bad as it was from certain enemies (like 1-2 turns) it's probably not good enough. Maybe stacking that with Blind in some way? But Mallow gives her very little time to win, as he 3HKOs and certainly gets his third turn before her third. So... confuse, then blind, then confuse, then attack, repeat... yeah I don't think this is working.