Dorothy (WoO) vs Miguel (CC): Heavies generally don't beat Miguel without holy resistance, even great ones.
Dorothy vs Deis (BoFs): Abstain, not sure which Deis form I vote on. I don't view Mirror Skin as effective against Deis 1's offence but I don't think it matters.
Dorothy vs Millenia (G2): Sleep blocker and spell-binding eye, yes.
Dorothy vs Nikki (MK): Ugh Dorothy speed headaches. I really need to figure those out. Still, she should get at least four turns between Nikki's first and second, and if those four are all Meltdowns that probably kills because... wait, what? Dorothy can do that? Gross.
Dorothy vs Angela (SD3): Dream Land.
Dorothy vs Toadstool (SMRPG): Can reflect the status, sure.
Dorothy vs Garan (SH2): Yeah, two-rounds.
Dorothy vs Flik (Suikos): Flik wishes he was more than mildly above average.
Dorothy vs Billy (XG): So apparently Dorothy one-rounds average durability easily with Melt Down x4. o_O Never realised that, I assumed her Sacrifice-move actually decreased proportionally with her HP but the raw base damage is huge. So if someone can't take her out in a single hit...
Dorothy vs Meliadoul (FFT): Yeah, sleep-immune Meliadoul's offence is just pathetic. Dorothy can overcome that without equipment unless she runs out of MP which seems unlikely.
Dorothy vs Nina (BoF1): Nina MUST open with Wall or she eats Dream Land, so instead Dorothy just Power Boosts and physicals. Nina is now heal-locked forever, and she runs out of healing before Dorothy runs out of Power Boost. If Nina ever takes a non-initiative action she gets lapped and dies, so status is out.
Dorothy vs Jack (WA1): Dream Land.
Hunter (FF5) vs Miguel (CC): Migs is competent.
Hunter vs Deis (BoFs): Either Deis handls this slugfest easily.
Hunter vs Millenia (G2): The eyes, they spellbind.
Hunter vs Nikki (MK): Faster, 2HKOs first.
Hunter vs Angela (SD3): Petrify.
Hunter vs Toadstool (SMRPG): Block sleep, heal-lock.
Hunter vs Garan (SH2): Garan vs. physical sluggers in Heavy.
Hunter vs Flik (Suikos): So uh Flik is 132% pdur, that isn't 2HKOed. Lightning halving still lets him 2HKO back. (Assuming you give him two L4s anyway. I do.)
Hunter vs Billy (XG): Hunter isn't winning with damage, so she equips the Killer Bow instead. Billy can haste and then get at least three turns before then to kill, though. (Killer Bow is 8% per shot, which works out to turn 3 with Rapidfire.)
Hunter vs Meliadoul (FFT): Mel's only 3HKOed, but even against naked Hunter's awful pdur she can't manage a 2HKO herself. Legendary weapon hype takes care of the rest.
Hunter vs Nina (BoF1): FF5 immunes both slow and paralysis. Uh, what status game does Nina have, exactly?
Hunter vs Jack (WA1): Two shots of ID, yeah.
Artea (Lufia2) vs Miguel (CC)
Artea vs Deis (BoFs): ID. Think he loses to Deis1 on raw offence anyway even if I decide to allow bunnies.
Artea vs Millenia (G2): Mm hm.
Artea vs Nikki (MK): More ID.
Artea vs Angela (SD3): Stone.
Artea vs Toadstool (SMRPG): Sleep. Man that casino stuff, it matters a lot.
Artea vs Garan (SH2): Doesn't need the casino for poison immunity!
Artea vs Flik (Suikos): Flik only does... 99% to Artea. (The stat topic's calculation of MDef appears incorrect, Artea reduces average magic damage by 13%, not 8%.) So! Doubt he can win.
Artea vs Billy (XG): I'll bite.
Artea vs Meliadoul (FFT): Ooh right, he had non-holy attack spells. Then yeah, no equipment = win anyway.
Artea vs Nina (BoF1): And ANOTHER match decided by casino stuff! Really?
Artea vs Jack (WA1): Jack takes like 18% extra from magic, not sure where this "Artea doesn't 2HKO" hype is coming from.
Dorothy 9-2
Hunter 4-8
Artea 4-8
