Godlike:
Ryu (BoF3) vs Profound Darkness (PS4): His type of match. Go Warrior, use Aura is one of the safest paths to victory probably. Does leave him open to sleep, but he can halve that so he's probably safe, and he may well have the MP for Tiamat in phase 3 anyway.
Middle:
Juan (S3) vs Justin (G1): Goes first, 2HKOs. (For what it's worth, I'd vote Juan even if I still banned storebought sleep protection, but I agree that if you take his damage the way the current stat topic does in its low-crit-rate form, he probably falls just short.)
Antenora (WA2) vs Max (SF1): "3HKOs first" sounds right, yeah.
Light:
Sara (BoF1) vs Palom (FF4)
FuSoYa (FF4) vs Rikku (FFX): Quick name the enemy Rikku needs to steal from to get a status FuSoYa doesn't immune! (Not silence or petrify.) If you can do it within 5 seconds I encourage you to vote for Rikku, but otherwise, fuck her. FAQ-bait + needs to farm items + Use isn't even remotely unique in-game makes he kinda despise her hype.