Middle
Sharon (Suikoden III) vs Tatjana (Arc the Lad: Twilight of the Spirits)
Yellow Scarf + her own status tricks presumably.
Hero (Dragon Quest) vs Robin (Fire Emblem: Awakening)
Hmm. Hero probably goes first due to Robin's meh movement, takes a shot of Sleep. Robin's Res is +1 on average which is okay but not amazing, but Sleep accuracy is pretty cruddy by endgame DQ1. (Although, unlike Hurtmore, it's also available earlier when it is useful... huh.) Robin 3HKOs, but can 2HKO if Ignis kicks in, which it's more likely to do thanks to 2x attacks... so, Sleep, eat damage, then heal if Ignis kicked in. If it didn't, try Sleep again then hope Ignis doesn't kick in, otherwise heal back up, and repeat, only doing Sleep attempts when Ignis didn't fire. Even if Sleep has real cruddy accuracy, when combined with the fact Hero has first go, this seems problematic... the stat topic is slightly off, *enemy* Sleep there's a 50/50 chance of waking up every turn, but PC Sleep is only a 1/3 chance of waking up + 1 guaranteed turn lost. And while it may not cancel evasion, FE precedent is asleep characters don't counter. So Sleep landing is pretty fatal here. Hmm... odds of Sleep hitting over 2 attempts is ~.64, odds of at least one Ignis firing in a single Brave string is 49%. So it is close at least. Let Robin go first and I'd definitely vote their way! Cursed low move range...
Light
No votes but commentary anyway!
Mack the Knife (Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars) vs Jeanne (Jeanne D'Arc)
Side note: I didn't see Jeanne transforming as particularly relevant last week, since it was Jeanne 2HKOing that mattered! (At least assuming Paula can 3HKO Jeanne.) Anyway, same dealie here based on the stat topic, Mack sounds faster than average speed so he should just 3HKO Jeanne with magic first and win. Or if summoning is allowed, summon -> set on fire. No vote since no SMRPG, but seems like Mack's match. EDIT: Never mind, Mack is apparently slower than average, so who knows. Depends on Mack durability then & summoning & stuff.
Chiepoo (Suikoden IV) vs Aegil (Rondo of Swords)
4HKO vs. a healer, good plan. Not even sure if Chiepoo even kills on physical + crit, and his crit rate is way too low.