I HAVE CHOICE PARALYSIS NOW
EDIT: Okay, picked Larsa BSB for the Mythril pick, that was easy. However, I have NO FUCKING IDEA of who to pick for the paid pull banner. For PRACTICAL purposes, I culled it down to the following:
Warrior of Light - nice compliment to his OSB, which I pulled on the Renewal draw, and has a fairly unique niche. Objective improvement to my holy game, gives me some armor synergy for FF1 and the holy game is relevant if I want to eventually sub-30 Shadow Dragon. HOWEVER, the latter may well be achievable with a Raines Legend Dive (I can get sub-40 runs just with Raines and some supporting DPS as is right now). And since I also drew Wol's SSB and Sarah's BSB on the Renewal banner, the need for FF1 synergy actually isn't terribly pressing anymore, I have a viable CM build with debuff-based mitigation and a very good Medica now.
Firion - Wrathable/Lifesiphonable instant MBlink remains amazing even now.
Edge - Water BSB to improve my game against Liquid Flame. Edge has -issues- building up gauge, though, and this would be more to fuel those 5* Ninja skills... which actually wouldn't be a bad idea when I have Rikku's Tidal Knuckle. It has Edge's name written all over it.
Lenna - FINALLY a healing SB for FF5 and a Mind stick that isn't completely ancient for FF5. However, how much do I -need- to cover that niche?
Bartz 2 - Water BSB to improve my game against Liquid Flame. Objectively not a great choice, though...
Setzer - Good compliment for his USB. Question is: do I -need- a more powerful debuff game when I already have Fujin BSB, Fran BSB and Faris USB?
Yuffie - Same ballpark as Edge. Same equip options, a character I like more and a more flexible skillset... but she has considerably less raw offense than he does.
Tidus - See Bartz. The BSB combos nicely with the OSB, at least... but there's that FFX banner looming with his USB and BSB2.
Vaan - Yes, it's pretty dang awesome. ON THE OTHER HAND, it also plays into "how much do I need debuffing?". To make matters more difficult, Vaan's BSB and USB are pretty much mutually exclusive. It risks being little more than a glorified +10 ATK to Vaan in spite of the on-paper package.
Sazh - I already have way too many 610 buffs, but his offers nice stackable debuffs and a neat instacast Wrath game, which is currently hard to replicate.
Someone help me.
EDIT: Some more for the lulzies possibilities: Palom, Kefka, Vivi, QUINA QUEN, Curilla, Penelo, Snow.