Well, dear reader, this has certainly been an illuminating bonus match! Mr. Cranbud had expected one or two characters, most probably our more successful Godlikes, to essentially run away with things, so to speak, with 30 or 40 votes apiece, if not more.
That has most definitely not been the case!
Instead, what we've seen is a truly spectacular range of characters, hailing from the ranks of RPGP contestants, unrated RPG characters, stars from other games, and even a few from truly unorthodox sources, such as cinema and literature. All, of course, are most welcome.
And here they are, dear reader:
All 140 Fan Appreciation Match vote-getters! 

Agrias Oaks (Final Fantasy Tactics) 2 votes

Alkaiser (SaGa Frontier) 1 vote

Alucard Tepes (Castlevania) 2 votes

Arc Ricolne (Arc the Lad series) 10 votes

Ari/Stanley Hihat Trinidad (Okage/Shadow King) 2 votes

Ash Lambert (Vandal Hearts) 1 vote

Ashley Riot (Vagrant Story) 4 votes

Ashton Anchors (Star Ocean 2) 2 votes

Auron (Final Fantasy X) 4 votes

Badrach (Valkyrie Profile) 1 vote

Bahamut (Final Fantasy series) 1 vote

Beowulf Kadmus (Final Fantasy Tactics) 1 vote

Billy Lee Black (Xenogears) 2 votes

Black Mage (Final Fantasy 1) 1 vote

Bleu (Shining Force) 1 vote

Blue (Saga Frontier) 1 vote

Bowser (Mario series) 1 vote

Calintz Jerevinan (Magna Carta) 2 votes

Captain of the Thames (Xenogears) 1 vote

Cecil Harvey (Final Fantasy 4) 1 vote

Celes Chere (Final Fantasy 6) 1 vote

Chaz Ashley (Phantasy Star 4) 1 vote

Choko (Arc the Lad series) 2 votes

Chris (Persona) 1 vote

Chris Lightfellow (Suikoden 3) 1 vote

Cid Highwind (Final Fantasy 7) 3 votes

Claude Kenni (Star Ocean 2) 4 votes

Cless Alvein (Star Ocean) 2 votes

Clive Winslet (Wild ARMs 3) 2 votes

Cloud Strife (Final Fantasy 7) 7 votes

Conan (Conan series) 1 vote

Cornet (Rhapsody) 1 vote

Crono (Chrono Trigger) 2 votes

Dante (Devil May Cry) 1 vote

Dart (Legend of Dragoon) 1 vote

Dekar (Lufia 2) 3 votes

Delita Hyral (Final Fantasy Tactics) 1 vote

Diablo (Diablo series) 1 vote

Dias Flac (Star Ocean 2) 2 votes

Drizzt Do'Urden (D & D) 6 votes

Edgar Roni Figaro (Final Fantasy 6) 1 vote

Edwin Odesseiron (Baldur's Gate 2) 1 vote

Emerald WEAPON (Final Fantasy 7) 1 vote

Emperor Cain (Xenogears) 1 vote

Fei Fong Wong (Xenogears) 3 votes

Fou Lu (Breath of Fire 4) 3 votes

Freya Crescent (Final Fantasy 9) 1 vote

Futch (Suikoden series) 1 vote

Gaff Gafgarion (Final Fantasy Tactics) 1 vote

Gau (Final Fantasy 6) 1 vote

Ghaleon (Lunar series) 1 vote

Gilgamesh (Final Fantasy series) 1 vote

Grahf (Xenogears) 1 vote

Gustav XIII (Saga Frontier 2) 1 vote

Guy (Lufia 2) 1 vote

Harold (?) 1 vote

Hotsuma (Shinobi) 1 vote

Hyuga Ricdeau (Xenogears) 6 votes

Id (Xenogears) 3 votes

Indalecio (Star Ocean 2) 2 votes

Jack Van Burace (Wild ARMs) 1 vote

Jet Enduro (Wild ARMs 3) 2 votes

Jogurt (Shining Force) 4 votes

Jon Irenicus (Baldur's Gate 2) 1 vote

Jowy Atreides (Suikoden 2) 1 vote

Katt (Breath of Fire 2) 4 votes

Kazan (Legaia 2: Duel Saga) 1 vote

Kefka (Final Fantasy 6) 2 votes

Kuja (Final Fantasy 9) 1 vote

Laguna Loire (Final Fantasy 8) 1 vote

Landis (Suikoden 3) 1 vote

Lenneth Valkyrie (Valkyrie Profile) 1 vote

Leo (Lunar EB) 1 vote

Leon Geeste (Star Ocean 2) 5 votes

Lezard Valeth (Valkyrie Profile) 1 vote

Link (Zelda series) 1 vote

Locke Cole (Final Fantasy 6) 2 votes

Loki (Valkyrie Profile) 3 votes

Lombardia (Wild ARMs series) 1 vote

Luc (Suikoden series) 2 votes

Luca Blight (Suikoden 2) 4 votes

Magus (Chrono Trigger) 13 votes

Mario (Mario series) 1 vote

Maxim (Lufia 2) 3 votes

McDohl (Suikoden) 1 vote

Melfice (Grandia 2) 1 vote

Miang Hawaa (Xenogears) 1 vote

Millennia (Grandia 2) 1 vote

Mog (Final Fantasy 6) 1 vote

Murray (?) 1 vote

Nameless One (Planescape: Torment) 1 vote

Nanaki (Final Fantasy 7) 1 vote

Nash Latkje (Suikoden series) 2 votes

Nemesis (?) 1 vote

Ness (Earthbound) 4 votes

Octillus the Gelficus Maximus (Shining Horse) 1 vote

Odd Eye (Shining Force 2) 2 votes

Orlandu (Final Fantasy Tactics) 2 votes

Palmer (Final Fantasy 7) 1 vote

Peco (Breath of Fire 3) 1 vote

Ragnar (Dragon Warrior 4) 1 vote

Raistlin Majere (D & D) 1 vote

Ramsus (Xenogears) 1 vote

Rand (Breath of Fire 2) 1 vote

Red Mage (Final Fantasy 1) 1 vote

Rei (Breath of Fire 3) 1 vote

Relm (Final Fantasy 6) 1 vote

Richter Belmont (Castlevania) 1 vote

Rikku (Final Fantasy X) 2 votes

Riou (Suikoden 2) 10 votes

Rofel (Final Fantasy Tactics) 1 vote

Rolf Landale (Phantasy Star 2) 1 vote

Rudy Roughknight (Wild ARMs) 2 votes

Rune (Phantasy Star 4) 1 vote

Rydia (Final Fantasy 4) 1 vote

Ryu (Breath of Fire series) 5 votes

Sabin Rene Figaro (Final Fantasy 6) 1 vote

Samus Aran (Metroid series) 1 vote

Sasarai (Suikoden series) 3 votes

Sephiroth (Final Fantasy 7) 8 votes

Setzer (Final Fantasy 6) 1 vote

Shadow (Final Fantasy 6) 5 votes

Slade (Shining Force 2) 1 vote

Solid Snake (Metal Gear series) 2 votes

Sora (Kingdom Hearts) 1 vote

Squall Leonheart (Final Fantasy 8) 1 vote

Strider Hiryu (Strider) 1 vote

Terra (Final Fantasy 6) 3 votes

Tifa Lockheart (Final Fantasy 7) 1 vote

Tommy Vercetti (Grand Theft Auto) 1 vote

Tosh (Arc the Lad series) 1 vote

Viktor (Suikoden series) 1 vote

Vyse (Skies of Arcadia) 1 vote

Wiegraf Folles (Final Fantasy Tactics) 2 votes

Yuber (Suikoden series) 2 votes

Yuffie (Final Fantasy 7) 1 vote

Yuri Hyuga (Shadow Hearts) 5 votes

Zell Dincht (Final Fantasy 8) 1 vote

Zidane Tribal (Final Fantasy 9) 1 vote