Messages

2001

General Chat / Re: Games you're playing: The 2009 edition.

« on: March 10, 2009, 08:09:02 PM »

Okami: Went back to this after trying my FFVII HDINS. Just cleared Oni Island, and headed to Kamui. Lost against the first boss there. Will try again soon, I guess. -.-

Oh, and I'm pretty much decided on the games decision now. Seems opinions of SF2 are a bit mixed, whereas all have agreed that BoF3 is a good game. Thanks a lot to all who commented.

2002

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 10, 2009, 07:28:21 PM »

I'd still personally like to see if Andy role-claims, but I guess it's not really necessary.

2003

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 10, 2009, 07:00:35 PM »

I'd still like to see if Andy has a role-claim to make. It's not likely to improve my opinion of him much, but I'd be interested to see if it changed other people's opinions for better or worse.

2004

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 10, 2009, 06:27:46 PM »

Ahh, afraid it's already been mentioned twice, I think.

2005

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 10, 2009, 06:25:28 PM »

Personally, if I had the guts to do it, I would hammer yoshi after his post when he posts, but that is my one big flaw in Mafia, I almost feel sly taking people out of the game.

As said before, I'm not surprised, to be honest - I can see that my arguments were flawed a few times, now that they've been pointed out. But, at the very least, I'd like to see if Andy would care to role-claim before this split is decided...

2006

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 10, 2009, 06:18:04 PM »

I posted earlier in the day that Snow > Andy > Excal/Rat. Since then, Excal's only seemed more townish in his actions, which is why I narrowed it down to these three as the main suspects. However, I then found myself agreeing with a lot of the logic that Cid presented here: http://www.rpgdl.com/forums/index.php?topic=3003.msg53191#msg53191
Now, forgive me for basing my opinions on someone else's portrayal of events, but that's a fairly convincing argument.
And, call it instinct if you will, but I just don't see a Snow/Rat team. I'd love to delve into this further, but I honestly can't. Andy seems like the main suspect of the three, and if he's town, then that only leaves me with Snow/Rat (and an almost-certain lynch.)

2007

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 10, 2009, 06:04:19 PM »

Yeesh. I've nothing much to add to what I said earlier. Vanilla Town, 99.9% sure Andy's scum, secondary thought of Snow/Rat.

I'll be interested in what the others have to say on this matter. And if either of them change votes to hit the other.
I, on the other hand, will almost certainly be keeping my vote as it is.

2008

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 10, 2009, 05:57:43 PM »

Cid, it's not that I favoured his survival over mine - hence the vote for Andy. I'm 99.9% sure Andy's scum, and if he's not, then I'm gone tomorrow. Risk I'm willing to take.
As for the other, I'm still torn between Snow & Rat.

Anyways, I'm not favouring his survival over mine - I'm saying that I favour neither in particular. Competent likely-town (based on elimination of my potential-scum) or incompetent town.

2009

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 10, 2009, 05:50:03 PM »

Ack, something else I just considered. Tom, can you please give a rundown of what you think, depending on if/then with the current lynch-suspects?

Seeing as you're a certain town, it's quite probable that you'll be nightkilled, as you've said yourself before. If that's the case, I'd like to have your opinions in the open for everyone to consider.

2010

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 10, 2009, 05:48:00 PM »

Sigh. On another topic, I'm also not sure what to make of Yoshi's declining to drop a vote on Excal, especially he's already done so once today. I mean, it'd make perfect sense for him to do so whether he's town or scum. Yoshi, are you somehow more confident in Excal's towniness than your own?

Not so much his towniness as a combination of towniness and competence. I know that I look incredibly suspicious to everyone, and I know that that's mostly because of flawed arguments. Excal, on the other hand, looks suspicious for being mostly quiet & voting Xanth Day1, but has provided good, clear arguments.
I know I'm incompetent town. He seems competent to me, and I'm really not sure on town/scum any more. Overall, I think it'd be more beneficial to town for him to survive.

Wow, this has turned into a total mess. More than it was before, I mean. =/

2011

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 10, 2009, 05:44:33 PM »

I'll look really stupid if Yoshi is scum, especially since I'm going on 'vibe' here rather than anything solid.

And I'll look really stupid if this doesn't work out. I'm pretty much certain that Andy's scum at this point, and if he flips town... Well, I'm pretty much gone tomorrow. And, if that happens... well, that's 4 town in 2 days, with only 9 players remaining? Not good.

2012

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 10, 2009, 05:34:28 PM »

I've.. already outlined my case on Excal, see earlier post. tldr; vote on xanth instead of meeple, lurkiness.

I'm just gonna point this out now, while I can - earlier, you criticised me, saying I had "never presented a case on the guy", yet now you're using the same reasoning I did. Interesting.

2013

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 10, 2009, 05:28:45 PM »

Yikes. Made it here with less time than I thought.

OK, firstly, no role-claim to be made, I'm afraid. All I'll say is that I'm town. Vanilla town, but town nonetheless.

Judging from previous posts here, it seems suspicions pretty much decided that it's me -v- Andy, with Snow & Excal as alternatives. I'm still suspicious of a Snow/Andy pair left, especially seeing as the majority have mentioned the four I said previously, except for Andy, who neglected to mention Snow in favour of Rat.

I'll admit, though - at the moment, I'm about as confused as everyone else seems to be.
I'm not gonna change my vote for Excal just to try and survive, because I don't think he's the major problem at this point. I will, however...
##Unvote: Snowfire.
##Vote: Andy.

Probably a little too late in the day, but it's worth a shot, I guess.

2014

General Chat / Re: Sunshine, lollipops and rainbows: G'morning, 2009!

« on: March 10, 2009, 05:10:04 PM »

Hmm. That's suddenly made me feel some pity for the hard-working people in my class, seeing as I'm always the lazy one who chooses to waste a little time going over things. ^^;

Also, woo! Should be getting work experience sometime in August... with Codemasters!
I'm happy enough getting a week in the games industry, regardless of the company. Now, I need to actually e-mail the guy about it, which means I have to plan the e-mail... Ah, crap. I'm never good at making myself sound good. ;_;

2015

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 09, 2009, 10:48:40 PM »

Ninja'd: Idly, Yoshi. How are you measuring activity, here?

Partially by consistent & frequent posting - hence Cid being the most clear (not entirely clear, ofc, 'cause of exactly what Excal said), as he's been consistently posting over all 3 days.
However, most of it's the depth within the posts. Snow, Delta, Xanth and Excal haven't been too consistent in their times, but when they do post, they post a lot with insight into every (or at least most) player(s).

2016

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 09, 2009, 10:16:53 PM »

Oh, I know it doesn't necessarily mean they're right! That's why I neglected to mention (or even consider) Ryogo in this - I was looking solely at those who'd been nightkilled, not lynched.

Hrm. I'm sure I had something from Alex Day2, but... apparently not. Ignore that part then, I guess.
Although, my suspicions still stand regarding Snow not being clear from Day1, for this reasoning:

If Meeple+Snowfire were scum, Snow would have no reason to refrain from hammering Xanth in sudden death, and would have had every reason earlier to get a vote down somewhere and try to roll with a train that wasn't Meeple.  OR be on or "mistakenly" hammer Meeple for town cred.  What he did do strikes me as the least likely course of action if he were Meeple's scum buddy.  Unless we're dealing with the least coordinated scum team ever...

Now this is interesting. Let's see... Looking over Snow's posts from Pages 2 & 3, there is not even a single mention of the Meeple/Xanth situation. So, if he were scum and then suddenly hammers Xanth, wouldn't that just raise suspicion? But then, if he hammers Meeple, he risks taking out an ally when there's a chance of townXanth going. If scumXanth, we aren't certain if Xanth has a role, which could be more helpful for scum. So, overall, seems like suspicion on Snow is still possible by this logic...

Just another insight into my way of thinking (and criticise it as you will, this is just how my mind works...), I'm still thinking the most probable town candidates are the people who've been most active throughout their time here, simply because they're staying in the spotlight & giving people more of a chance to read into their thinking. Now, I know me & Tom are town, and the other "most active" is, without a doubt, Cid.
From there, slightly less consistent in activity, we have Excal, Snow, Delta & Xanth, and then, the least active are seemingly Andy & Rat.
Add into that my previous arguments, and... well, back where I started, with Rat added in (who, I'll admit, I completely forgot about >.>) - Snow > Andy > Excal/Rat.

2017

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 09, 2009, 08:18:48 PM »

OK, just to clarify one thing that a few people seem to have picked up on...
Where it was said "If townExcal, then I'd assume scumAlex and (most probably) scumTom", that was at that time and also not something I stated for certain (hence the "I'd assume"). Obviously, since then, we've had other information to tell us that Tom & Alex are/were clearly town, and I'm still somewhat suspicious of Excal for the reasons I was assuming this at the time.
I'll admit that it was probably a mistake to announce it outright like that, as though it was a certainty in my mind, but I can guarantee it most definitely wasn't.

Oh, and seeing as I didn't in my previous post...
##Vote: Snowfire.

It's usually somewhat frowned upon to think about the rationale behind lynch targets, as you can go round in circles trying to out-think the scum and get nowhere.

But surely that logic goes in circles too. I mean, maybe scum think you won't look at the lynch targets and... you can see where this is going.

Oh, as it happens, Xanth... Why do you feel that Snow's Day1SD actions clear him? Or, more, why is it that you trust that Snow saying "Can we vote someone else?" means he's automatically town? Seems like that could have been WIFOM from him...

2018

Tournaments / Re: Beauty Contest 1-D

« on: March 09, 2009, 07:28:56 PM »

Looked up pics for these, or otherwise I wouldn't be able to vote on a single match. ;_;

Miyuki (XS) vs. Syrene (FE8) - Green hair. :>
Mitsuru (P3) vs. Karin (Enchanted Arms) - Similar figure, better hair & face.
Velvet (OS) vs. Anastasia (WA2) - No amount of blue hair can save you here!
Grune (ToL) vs. Edea (FF8) - Not Edea. Also, not actually bad.
Margarete (SH) vs. Ilyana (FE9/10) - Definitely a winner. That, and (the picture I found of) Margarete has hu~ge lips.
Elincia (FE10) vs. Angela (SD3) - Yeah, I just don't think Elincia's anything special, green hair or not.
Clarissa (WAXF) vs. Zeal (CT) - ...
Priscilla (FE7) vs. Serra (FE7) - Ehh, need better images maybe, but Priscilla's better from what I can find.
Persephone (WA5) vs. Raquel (WA4) - Ohh... Ack, I guess I'll go with Raquel. But damn close.
Viola (ES) vs. Antenora (WA2) - Seems I don't like the ES art style. >.>
Kika (Suikos) vs. Mara (DW4) - Yeesh. Never thought Kika was anything special, but Mara... Ouch.
Misha (AT) vs. Belleza (SoA:L) - As much as she reminds me of the creepy lady from Okami, she's better looking.
Lenneth (VPs) vs. Zerase (S5) - Sure, she wins, but is it possible to find a picture where she's remotely happy?
Rose (LoD) vs. Karla (FE7) - If Fiora and Karla had been swapped round, though...
Sabrina (PKMN) vs Nikea (S5) - Meh. Best of a bad choice.
Fiora (FE7) vs. Riviera (GL2) - The pic took a while to find, but was almost certainly worth finding.

2019

Tournaments / Re: Beauty Contest 1-C

« on: March 09, 2009, 05:41:43 PM »

Ugh. And laziness hits today. I'll probably find pictures for the many I don't know some other day, including every match on 1-D. >.>

Lyndis (FE7) vs. Titania (FE9/10) - Green hair > Red hair. Also, Lyn = Win.
Seneca (SuikoTactics) vs. Elena (FF7) - It's tough, but Seneca's costume wins it for her.
Legretta (TotA) vs. Maya Shchroedinger (WA3) - Not thinking highly of Maya here.
Rise (P4) vs. Rozalin (Dis2)
Miki (CC) vs. Cleo (Suiko1) - Ehh, I guess.
Cissnei (FFCC) vs. Tifa (FF7) - Tifa's average at best. (Which, IMO, is the AC look.)
Lucia (Suiko3) vs. Emeralda (XG) - Ooh, close, but the green hair takes it.
Rinoa (FF8) vs. Heather (FE10) - Eh. Never really thought much of Heather.
Tethys (FE8) vs. Miang (XG) - Yay for not remembering one of my own noms! Anyway, Tethys takes this easily.
Chris (S3) vs. Refia (FF3) - Don't see the attraction of Chris.
Yuna (FFX) vs. Natalia (TotA) - Yeah, Yuna's nothing special.
Tanith (FE9/10) vs. Linde (FE:SD) - Meh, don't think much of Tanith.
Freya (VPs) vs. Aelia (VP) - Long hair > short hair. Also, more feminine.
Lethe (FE9/10) vs. Paine (FFX-2) - Because Paine is... meh.
Sheena (ToS) vs. Reimi (SO4) - Nice hair and figure, which is more than can be said for Sheena.
Judith (ToV) vs. Shanoa (CV: OoE)

Fear my lack of gaming knowledge!

Edit: Went through nomination topic for pics. Still need quite a few though. Some other time.

Edit: Looked up rest. Also, there better be a 1-E at least, because Viese hasn't been in yet! D:

2020

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 09, 2009, 04:55:36 PM »

Hmm, seems I've somehow fallen under the hammer of suspicion. While I can understand that by first-day logic - I know I'd be suspicious considering Strago's silence followed by replacement - I'd still like people to consider at least leaving that vote temporarily, so that we can clarify if there is a better case as opposed to "Well, he's been around less." We've seen how that's screwed us over before, looking at the Ryogo-lynch.

Also, thought came to me earlier - why was Bard the victim on the first day? He wasn't the only player to be posting a lot. Decided to look back at his posts... (For all posts, I've cut out parts referring solely to Meep's actions.)

I cited the last part because I am befuddled why you would be clearing up linguistic and/or argumentative differences between Excal and Xanth. As I feel that you should only protect someone of whose alignment you are certain, and given that townies do not know anyone's alignment but their own (I will not consider masons at this point), I find it odd for you to defend someone else and explain away their behaviour.

Xanth is perfectly capable of doing so himself.

I want to mention as well that SnowFire befuddles me. The way I see it, the post firsts chastises Andrew for chasing lurkers who haven't posted, only to... chase an alleged lurker yourself. It also feels like a little panic-mongering by ascribing the various effects Delta's present behaviour could have while knowing all too well we have no way of telling which one is the relevant one.

Also, voting people for posting only once and then not again strikes me as incredibly silly since... guess what? You've effectively made two posts in this day as well, meaning you fit your own criteria for classic scum lurking behaviour!

Since we are nearing the deadline, I've taken the liberty of examining the other cases which seem most prevalent to get a lynch, namely Xanth and Snowfire.

Snowfire:
I can accept a lynch on Snowfire based on how useless he's been so far. However, inactivity grades lower to me on the MUST LYNCH radar than someone who's confusing and befuddling. Snowfire, I really, really, really cannot say with good conscience that I think you have been any bit productive to Day 1. Please either change this with all rapid haste or I'll shift my undivided lynching attention to you.

Xanth:
Please stop referring to previous games and whatnot. It is not relevant to this game, and arguments like "OH BUT LAST GAME" just don't work for me. If you want to get lynched today, by all means continue with it. Also stop using sarcasm. "I like how people jump on blah blah lazy bastard blah blah key evidence". Well shit, it's Day 1 and you're constantly excusing yourself, what are you thinking? Ridiculing people with sarcasm because they find an act of yours suspicious doesn't sit well with me. For all that, I find it pretty ridonculous as well that we need so many updates on your sparse schedule; others post less than you do and they don't keep excusing themselves!

At this point,
Meeple > Xanth > Snowfire on my "suspect of scum" list. Other candidates aren't listed as it isn't pertinent right now, but I do feel Delta's being his usual confusing self. The others haven't left a strong enough impact on me for me to pursue something actively. I'm not interested in throwing around minor suspicions so strongly on Day 1, I'll save that for after the flip and Day 2.

I'm around, thrown off my momentum by this announcement. Want to hear Xanth if possible.

I do not understand why SnowFire is desperate to post for the end of today. I'll withhold further opinions on it until the post or something, I don't know.

OK. I'll state now that I'm not 100% certain if this means much, but, as Cid stated earlier, there's a good chance the mafia in this game aren't entirely sure of what they're doing, based around the fact that there was a Day1 lynch and then the Limited Mason was killed. Which led me to wonder why Bard was killed.
Looking over those posts, I'm very tempted to comment on how suspicious Snow seems, for obvious reasons. Main problems here are Bard's point in that final post, as well as the fact that only two people seemed to look at Snow in great detail - Bard & Alex.
Only others I'm inclined to wonder about are Delta & Xanth, as those are mentioned in the post where he said "I'll save that for after the flip and Day 2." Can't help but feel that this post was somewhat influential in his selection as target.

My suspicions on Andy & Excal still remain as they were - current idea is Snow > Andy > Excal, but those three are pretty damn close in my books at the moment.

tl;dr - Snow seems suspicious because both Bard & Alex were saying he was scummy before getting killed.

2021

General Chat / Re: WTF?! Questions

« on: March 09, 2009, 04:13:03 PM »

1)What's your favorite Final Fantasy Job Class?
Hrm. I'm really not sure. Instinct says Dragoon, 'cause they were always my favourite, if only because of FFIV. Since then, though, I'd lean towards either Blue Mage or Black Mage. I guess... for the actual class abilities, Blue Mage. For the look/style of fighting, Dragoon.

2)What's your favorite fantasy race that is not Human?
Tonberry! I love the Tonberries (sp?). I've got a plushie Tonberry by my window that's one of my favourites out of my figurine/plushie collection. =P

3)Who is your favorite historical leader of a country not your own? Why?
Leon Trotskii (if he counts. If not, probably Lenin for similar reasons). Why...? Probably conditioning from my sister. =P  A good leader who actually seemed to have an ounce of intelligence (can't say the same for most leaders today...) and looked out for the people. Got screwed over by the workings of the country.

ASSUME THE FOLLOWING FOR QUESTIONS 4-6
God can call you on your cell phone. He appears as "GOD" in big friendly letters, and he has a personalized ringtone. Sometimes it's important, more often than not, the divine dude is just bored and talks about things way beyond your ken. Do you answer your phone...

4)If you're having a bad day?
Almost certainly wouldn't. I rarely talk to anyone when I'm in a really bad mood, so I wouldn't want to talk to someone who wouldn't interest me at all.

5)If you're having sex?
Hmm... Probably the first couple of times, but if it just kept happening, then eventually I'd get pissed off and not bother.

6)If you're in the shower?
Yeah, sure, why not?

~~~

7)You are given the power of perfect empathy. Not only can you immediately tell what someone is feeling, you can tell everything they're feeling. Sometimes, you understand things so beneath the surface that the people you're dealing with don't even comprehend it yet. Eventually, you realize that all of your friends think you're an intrusive dick. Do you willingly give up your power if offered, you dick?
Haha, most of my friends think I'm an intrusive dick already, so this'd be an awesome power. Like hell I'd give that up.

8)What kind of shoes do you wear most of the time? If they're made for a particular sport, do you partake in that sport?
Uhh.. Whatever I feel like wearing, to be honest. I have, like, 2-3 pairs of shoes, and I'll randomly alternate between them for no real reason, so there's no specific type.

9)What is your favorite season? Why?
Spring. I'm not good with extreme sun (not for the heat, it's just too bright) and I'm VERY intolerant to cold. Autumn & Winter are too cold, Summer's too bright, so Spring.

10)Tell an anecdote about someone doing something inexplicably hot (in the attractive sense) or, you know, don't if you don't feel like sharing.
Meh, nothing to share. Unfortunately.

2022

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 08, 2009, 10:23:17 PM »

Yeesh, I cut my other post short to let other people comment on what's happened, and return to find I'm suddenly one of, if not the top candidate for next lynch.

Looking back at my previous analysis post, a few things have changed... Obviously, we've had some stuff from 3/4 of the quiet guys - still waiting on Rat, which really isn't helping that case at all...
So, to break those down... Excal's contributed more in these last few posts than I think the majority have in the time since I came in. That does help clear the suspicion around him a little, since the majority of that was based around the lack of posting. Of course, it still doesn't help that he's the only unknown left who voted Xanth.
Snowfire, I'm becoming more suspicious of, if only for the low post content in general.

In other words, if we lynch Excal and he flips scum, AndrewRogue will look really evil.

Looking back at this, this has caught my attention... This is implying that the alternative is we lynch Excal, he flips town and Andy's pretty much clear. There's one other alternative I can think of, and that's the possibility of Meeple/Andy/Snow as scum. If that were the case, this argument would be the perfect defence - attack against Excal, flips as town, and then Andy's seemingly home free.

Andy, I feel I should start by arguing the vote against me:

So while Excal is a viable candidate, Yoshi's own logic for that vote also speaks against him. This seems like really sloppy argumentation to me, and makes me rather uncomfortable.

The main reason for this vote was the same reasons I'm giving for suspicions in this post - low post total & content. The votes simply supported that - I understand that the votes will make me look somewhat suspicious, but there's not really much I can do to help that, seeing as I wasn't here for Day1. All I'll ask is that people don't jump to conclusions based on me not being here before.
As for you, I'm still quite suspicious. You've not really given much insight in your latest post - you've said me & Excal look suspicious, and you said Rat's vote on Ryogo was. I'm interested in knowing why you think that's more of a scum move than a town making sure the potential scum falls. (Sure, he was actually town, but that's hindsight for ya.)

Overall, I've got suspicions regarding Andy/Snow/Excal.
Out of these, my main problem is with Andy, mostly because of the Snow quote from earlier in the post. If we do vote Andy and he flips scum, I think it's fairly certain that one of the other two is.


~AndyNinja - Hrm. I've already commented regarding my case against Alex. It seemed logical at the time, but hindsight's a bitch. With regards to my posts, I personally think I'm saying a fair bit, at least presenting my thoughts on each person - we saw the problem with a single-minded chase before, with Tom chasing Xanth.

~Xanth & CidNinjas - Hrm, nothing to comment on here.

2023

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 08, 2009, 08:57:00 PM »

##Unvote: Excal
No harm in this - might as well see what's said and then decide. Can always re-vote if needed.

Granted, I want to hear EVERYONE's input on this. Andy, Xanth and ET havent spoken yet, and I want their input on today's matters.

Rat too. Strangely, I'm particularly interested in hearing what Rat has to say. Probably because I'm leaning town, but still relatively unsure on that, so I'd like to see what could develop there.

2024

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 08, 2009, 08:31:44 PM »

Just to look over posts from the previous 2 days...
(I've taken out those who've been killed already, just so I can focus on who's left.)
Ryogo (4): Rat, Xanth, Tom
EvilTom (2): Andy, Delta
Excal (3): Cid, Snowfire, Yoshiken

Meeple (5):  Andy, Rat, Cid, Delta
Xanth (4): Excal, EvilTom

OK, looking at these... Wow. I'm inclined to say the votes alone point directly to one person - Excal.
##Vote: Excal.
There's also the lurking problem - low number of posts with relatively little content. I'm still surprised there was no comment after removing the vote from Tom...

Snow - I still have my suspicions here - I mentioned those yesterday on the idea of an Alex/Snow scum combo. While Alex has been proved to be town, you've not. I'd like to know your reasons for voting Excal yesterday, since you only mentioned reasons for not voting Tom.
Cid - I'm definitely leaning towards town. Was a major factor in Meeple going, and started the Excal train which, at this point, I think is probably right.
Tom - Nothing much to say, really. Town, simple as that.
Xanth - Waiting to see your comments on the latest developments. I haven't really got much out of your Day2 posts, in all honesty.
Andy - Talk! Definitely suspicious, if only for the fact that you've not been posting. Meep vote good, Tom vote bad, so neutral going by votes. Probably second-most suspicious for me at this point.
Delta - Hrm. Cid does hold a good point on the Meeple-vote. That, and I wasn't particularly sure on the role (thanks for clearing that up, Cid), so nothing particularly bad to say. Still haven't found anything particularly good either, though, so I'm only slightly leaning town here for the Meeple-vote.
Rat - Talk more! Aside from that, I'm leaning town here. Voted Ryogo, said Excal would be 2nd and gave reasons, and voted Meeple Day1. Seems fairly town to me, although that depends on how things develop.

Edit: Excalninja - doesn't change much until he posts again.

2025

Forum Games / Re: Simpsons Mafia DAY THREE

« on: March 08, 2009, 06:46:40 PM »

Wow. That's either really clever or really dumb of scum. Seems like there are some things for me to seriously consider here, especially as, up until late yesterday, I was still suspicious of Alex.
Most suspicious in my eyes now are Excal, Andy & Delta, in that order.
Excal/Andy have both been quite quiet, which seems more than a little suspicious. Excal's higher on the list for the sole reason that he was the first to unvote Tom after Alex's role revelation, yet didn't vote anyone else or even so much as comment on his thoughts on the matter.
Delta... A little more complex than just "he's not around much". Firstly, Alex seems to have been focusing on him quite a bit - knowing the role now, I can't help but wonder why so much attention has been paid specifically to Delta (and also Snow, as it happens, although that was in reverse - Day2, he suddenly took all attention off Snow, giving seemingly bad reasons.) With that said, I'd safely say that if scumSnow -> scumDelta, and if townDelta -> townSnow. (Those don't work in reverse, mind.)
The problem with Delta is the Meeple vote. Even ignoring Rat's unnoticed vote, that would have pushed Meeple into the lead on votes. That's either a very crazy strategy or town, and it just seems too crazy to even risk, unless Xanth is scum with role.

I'm interested in knowing what others think on the matter regarding Delta.
And I can't help but feel there's a flaw in my logic regarding Alex's role, so I'd muchly appreciate some feedback on that.