Djinn, have some taste. Dekar's art is hideous, and this isn't a personality contest (not that I'd vote for him on that, either).
Sephiroth (FF7) vs Leon Magnus (ToD): I suppose.
Irvine (FF8) vs Zelgius (FE9/10): Very easy. Zelgius is hot in the manly way (unlike, say, Dekar <_<), especially shirtless. <3
Glenn (CC) vs Ryu (BoF1): uh
Shu Shirakawa (SRT) vs Jade Curtiss (TotA): .... ewwwww
Jenna Angel (DDS) vs Sigurd (XG): Hotness.
Ramza Beoulve (FFT) vs Zack Fair (FF7): Nose.
Gilliam Yeager (SRT) vs Jowy Atreides (S2): Also, for the record, Djinn, you lose your wager. <.< That said, not-a-kid vote.
Lawfer (VP1) vs Dojima (P4): Dojima's good for SMT, but Lawfer is hotness.
Zelos Wilder (ToS) vs Indalecio (SO2): Ew.
Fayt Leingod (SO3) vs Ferid (Sui5): Man, Ferid is awesome. I'm never sure just how attractive he is, though. Abstain.
Cloud Strife (FF7) vs Sanger Zonvolt (SRT): I'd probably vote Sanger here, but eh, AC/modern FF7 art saves Cloud.
Jecht (FF10) vs Vigoro (SoA): VIGORO? Infinite fail, unless I've seen all the wrong art of him.
Kratos Aurion (ToS) vs Lucius (FE7): Fire Emblem is prettier than Tales... close to uniformly.
Gatrie (FE 9/10) vs Felix (GS): Ahaha Golden Sun art.
Seed (Sui2) vs Dekar (Lufia2): Ahaha Lufia art, ahahaha Dekar in general.
Rufus (VP2) vs Kuja (FE9): I... guess? Eh, people have done the attractive tranny better than Kuja.
Edgar Roni Figaro (FF6) vs Luther Lansfeld (SO3):
Seifer Almasy (FF8) vs Albel Nox (SO3): Albel? Really?
Dist the Runny (TotA) vs Luke fon Fabre (TotA): DIST is... not attractive. Luke's fine.
Marth (FE1) vs Greg (WA5): Greg's hot.