Beatrix: 13
Lucian: 1

OblivionKnight
Blind works for me as well.

Excal
Lucian had my vote, then came the Blind revelation.

Gourry
Bah. I don't remember if Blind worked that often, but Beatrix is comparable in power with Lucian. While it wouldn't take more than one or two rounds of Shining Bolt + Round Rip Saber combos to beat Beatrix, a blind Lucian isn't going to hit anything.

Wave Existance
Beatrix has crappy damage....but at least she has healing. Lucian has crappy damage and no healing.

GenocideHeart
The Blind thing would normally work... except that Lucian has a habit of locking opponents in a Stun status with the exaggerated number of hits Shining Bolt does. I don't recall Beatrix being exaggeratedly fast, so I, just barely, give this to Lucian. But it is REALLY close and could go either way.

Dekar TKB
I'd have never thought of Blind had it not been mentioned, but...Healing+Blind. Lucian really can't do enough damage to counter it.